Sebastien Chabal knocks out Marc Giraud


Mourad Boudjellal on building Toulon


Matt Toomua Falcon vs the All Blacks


Tony Buckley's big handoff on Simon Shaw


Buck Shelford tribute


Random great tries from 2008


Schalk Brits runs into Wayne Barness


Visser penalised for preventing lineout


Isa Nacewa tackle on Gareth Owen

Monday, November 03, 2008

Jason Spice coathangers Joe Maddock

Jason Spice coathangers Joe Maddock

Cardiff Blues progressed to the EDF Energy Cup semi-finals after a well deserved 24-18 home win over Bath in Cardiff on Friday night.

In the second half Bath were awarded a penalty try after wing Joe Maddock was prevented from scoring a try. The resultant kick conversion was pretty interesting too.

It all came about from a fantastic passage of play, sparked by the ever impressive kiwi winger Joe Maddock who streaked through the line of defence and looked set to score a fairly simple looking try.

As he stepped inside the covering defence though, it was another kiwi, Jason Spice, who stuck out an arm and caught Maddock around the neck, sending him spiralling to the ground.

The referee, Nigel Owens, awarded a penalty try but decided against the yellow card as he felt the tackle from Spice was accidental.

Maddock, who was probably still a bit dazed following the incident, had his kick charged down from directly in front of the posts, as Richard Mustoe shot off the line. An interesting clip, with some perhaps thinking that Spice should have been yellow carded too. Opinions will vary no doubt.


Time: 0:38

Posted at 10:58 am | 20 comments

Viewing 20 comments

Cory November 04, 2008 1:07 am

Great running from Maddock.. I think the call was fair, it looked accidental, not malicious.That is the first time i've seen a conversion been charged down!

· Reply · Report

sambobly November 04, 2008 1:14 am

Stephen Larkham charged one down in a test against the springboks in 2000 I think. It was brilliant.

· Reply · Report

Cheis November 04, 2008 1:36 am

was butch james off the pitch? why did he take the conversion himself?

· Reply · Report

K Lu November 04, 2008 4:16 am

I agree with Cory - looked like Spice just got caught with a sidestep and tried to recover, nothing deliberate I think. Good call and great rundown of the conversion! I'm surprised its not fully attempted more often.

· Reply · Report

billybob November 04, 2008 5:30 am

not intentional but still a high tackle which is a yellow surely?spice isnt exactly the cleanest of players either

· Reply · Report

sobered November 04, 2008 6:48 am

hmm..if u give a penalty try..some1 should be yellow carded right?

· Reply · Report

Anonymous November 04, 2008 7:31 am

I thought it was illegal to charge a conversion for a penalty try? Obviously not, I guess ...

· Reply · Report

Anonymous November 04, 2008 7:48 am

cheis - Butch didn't play and Cuthbert was kicking but went off injured (Y)

· Reply · Report

Fridge November 04, 2008 7:49 am

Our winger charged a kick down once. Had something to do with the very long run up their kicker had! Our kicker got to the tee before he did!

· Reply · Report

dr November 04, 2008 10:37 am

wasn't malicious but I thought it is sort of a rule that any incident deemed severe enough to give a penalty try, also deserves at least a yellow card.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous November 04, 2008 11:39 am

i think the expression is clothes lined, when i say coat hangered i thought we were gonna see a do it yourself rugby abortion-feetham

· Reply · Report

Anonymous November 04, 2008 12:56 pm

I'm not so sure.. I think a Penalty Try and a yellow should have been given there.. Could have changed the result

· Reply · Report

Flooz November 04, 2008 2:39 pm

it was an absolute yellow card.nigel owens is welsh,... no?

· Reply · Report

Anonymous November 04, 2008 7:26 pm

I am pretty sure the ref got that completely wrong. As i understand it a penalty try is not given as a punitive measure, that is the role of the yellow card. A penalty try is only given if the conditions are such that without infringing the laws a try would otherwise have been scored. As such to award a try in this incident you would have to argue that had Spice not made the high tackle a try would have been scored. This is a hard case to make as if he was able to get a hand on him then he could likely have made a legal tackle - although this, obviously, does not apply to all situations. In this case i reckon it should have been a penalty on the 5 meter and a yellow for Spice.

· Reply · Report

Alain November 04, 2008 7:30 pm

the charge down was perfect..he started running at the same time as the kicker did..

· Reply · Report

Anonymous November 04, 2008 7:46 pm

simon says "yellow. . ."

· Reply · Report

Don November 06, 2008 9:38 am

YELLOWNo questions asked.

· Reply · Report

danythegod December 13, 2008 2:52 pm

puta** le vieux cul de catin abus!le pire c'est qu'ils se font contrer juste apres lors de la transfo! il n'y a pas de justice...dans le rugby surtout pour les clubs franais mais a c'est une autre histoire.bath est une tres belle quipe! avec sale ils iront loin! mais pas trop et ni avec leicester car l'USAP vaincra!!! GOOOOOO USAP!

· Reply · Report

englishcenter December 16, 2008 1:10 am

Lol Danny shui anglais mais j'ai vecu en france pendant 6 ans a Paris.je sui daccord avec toi ke lusap ira plus loin ke ces 3 autres ekipes surtout avec l'arive de Dan carter, et nous avons vu dernierement ke Perpignan a battu leicester.jaimeriat mieu ke le stade francais aille loin, mais ca risque po trop je pense

· Reply · Report

Gaz January 11, 2009 12:10 pm

In response to the anonymous post, saying the ref got it completely wrong and it should have been a 5m penalty, I think Bath may have had some complaints since Maddock managed to score anyway.I think it was a good decision as Maddock would have probably been under the posts otherwise.Yellow card is 50/50 depends whether it was intentional or not which is pretty hard for a ref to judge.

· Reply · Report

Commenting as Guest | Register or Login

All comments are moderated and will be removed immediately if offensive.
 
Site Meter