Stade Francais win in clash with Pau

Pass Around The World with Allianz

George Gregan's halfback Masterclass

Some of the greatest amateur rugby hits

All Blacks fined for waterboy Messam

James Schrader's sensational try saver

Alesana Tuilagi crunches big winger!

Sensational Stepper Nehe Milner-Skudder

Richie McCaw reveals breakdown secrets

Tuesday, April 14, 2009

Munster surge in the semis with big win over the Ospreys

Munster surge in the semis with big win over the Ospreys

Heineken Cup champions Munster once again showed why theyre the front runners for this years competition as they tore apart a below par Ospreys side at Thomond Park on Sunday.

The 43-9 win now sets up a mouth watering clash with Irish rivals Leinster, who themselves were victorious on the weekend, beating Harlequins 6-5 is a far tighter game.

Munster led the first half 16-6, but it was two second half tries in two minutes for Keith Earls, and 17 points from flyhalf Ronan OGara, that helped the home side run away with the game.

James Hook managed three penalties for the visitors, but lack of creativity and structure ultimately made their big name players look lost in a sea of red.

The way in which Munster dominated the Ospreys, who are littered with Welsh talent, not only shows that Munster will be the odds on favourites to lift the cup once again, but it also raises questions about British & Irish Lions selections.

Many of the Welsh players might have played themselves out of contention, while a few of the Munster guys will have put their hands up.

The Heineken Cup semi-finals will be played on the first weekend of May, while the final is at Murrayfield in Edinburgh on May 23.

Time: 07:20

Posted by Rugbydump at 2:00 pm | View Comments (59)

Viewing 59 comments

Anonymous April 14, 2009 12:56 pm

first comment:D anyway down to important stuff munster for the heineken cup this year nobodys going to stop them. and if they did do a tour of SH teams i still think they would only beat about half of them.....NH rugby has a long way to go yet!!

· Reply · Report

Mentallymadmax April 14, 2009 1:08 pm

Munster look a class above the rest currently. But as a Tigers fan, when Tigers get it right, and we have Mauger back, we could be in with a good shout.

Munster Tigers final would be awesome! I really think Tigers can upset the odds when they play like they have been in the last 2 months. Bath game aside, with the late back line changes.

· Reply · Report

Scotsdale April 14, 2009 1:11 pm

Thanks for the highlights RD.. been waiting patiently. :)

That Mafi pass is awesome. I bet the Irish wish he could play for them..

· Reply · Report

Anonymous April 14, 2009 1:16 pm

Cant blaim the Ospreys backs for this performance- their pack was obliterated and generated no quick ball or go foward.

I cant see leinster beating this Munster team

· Reply · Report

jordan April 14, 2009 1:36 pm

Munster do look like a quality side, and from what limited access to the Heineken cup that I have it would seem that they will go all the way.

That being said, Mafi's offload seemed to be forward, and i am not sure if i would have awarded the final try (not that it would have made any difference)

· Reply · Report

Anonymous April 14, 2009 1:38 pm

Munster are a great side.

But it's a known fact that Ospreys are pretenders.

Well done Munster, they're on fire at the moment

· Reply · Report

Michael April 14, 2009 1:45 pm

Munster are obscenely good at the moment. The only Super 14 team I could see beating them at the moment is the Crusaders.

I cant understand why the Aussies havent tried to get Paul Warwick back yet- the guy is absolutely world class. He never seems to put a foot wrong.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous April 14, 2009 1:50 pm

Im a Leinster supporter and i dont see how we have any answer to that Munster team.

Lets hope we get a bit of luck.

· Reply · Report

Will Topps April 14, 2009 1:51 pm

"if they did do a tour of SH teams i still think they would only beat about half of them.....NH rugby has a long way to go yet!!"

Get real, we do get to see the S14 up here in the Northern Hemisphere you know.

The Chiefs are by far and away your most exciting team going forward, but they leak points like a colander. They conceded over 30 to the winless Lions!

The Crusaders have looked distinctly average this season, The Bulls have been poor away from home, The 'Canes don't even have a fly half. All the Aussie teams are missing strength in the key positions, front row, halfies, with the exception of the Force, who have Giteau, but a dearth of players in other positions.

Heineken Cup rugby is remarkable similar to test match rugby, and I'm afraid the southern hemisphere teams just play too fast and too loose to be contenders in it, were they able to enter.

If I had to pick one SH team I think would be able to win the HC, it'd be the Sharks, but they wouldn't stand up to a team like Munster, Leicester or Toulouse in the latter stages.

The NH is king of club rugby, for better or for worse, whilst the SH continues to dominate internationally.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous April 14, 2009 2:00 pm

will topps statement of "Get real, we do get to see the S14 up here in the Northern Hemisphere you know."

i wrote the first comment and im from ireland. i was in thomand park at the weekend when they won.

the only reason they won is because O'Gara was kicking everything he put his hands on.

thats the only reason ireland beat italy by so much in the 6 nations...when he got yellow carded the irish back line were able to run with a ball.

which is the reason SH is better than NH. they run with a ball while all NH teams just try play tennis with it!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous April 14, 2009 2:04 pm

munster are awesome a complete team it seams whereas ospreys are lost and have been for a while now

the scoreline however had a gloss to it, the last 2 tries looked dodgy to me, clear forward pass from mafi, and warwicks knee and foot did touch the line

didnt affect the result though, warwick dg's were great JW gets one from 3 attempts from half that distance and he is a wizard. what does that make warwick...god???

· Reply · Report

Madflyhalf April 14, 2009 2:06 pm

Wallace is 7 of The B&I Lions.

I can't see anyone else, now.


· Reply · Report

FrankyH April 14, 2009 2:15 pm

Anyone ever thought about the fact that the NH sides are taking their brand of six nations/test match rugby (yawn), and combining it with the growing influx of the SH players plying their trade up north.. creating well rounded sides that not only have the yawn factor taken care of, but possess the SH flair too?
Howlett, Tipoki, Mafi, Warwick, Elsom, Contepomi, Evans etc

Would Ireland have beaten the Ospreys like that? Or was Ireland vs Wales pretty much a tight affair?

Food for thought.
I'm a fan of both top competitions/tournaments. :)

· Reply · Report

Anonymous April 14, 2009 3:31 pm

I put Munster's run this season down to one thing, Tony McGahan. He was the brains behind the win last year, all Munster offered in 2007 was an experienced team that could hold and recycle ball through the phases, & which possessed a very strong defence (due to McGahan). Now that McGahan has full reign, we are now seeing probably the most devastating Munster team yet. We no longer depend on a midfield break with Howlett to off load to, or a rumbling pack. It is now a completely expansive game. Take note how O'Gara didn't kick ball from hand at all in the 1st half. The way the players are trusting eachother and keeping the ball alive, and the boyz on the bench coming on and showing great hunger.

Also take into account that without 8 of their starting Internationals, McGahan has still kept them at the top of the Magners League. He's doing an excellent job and has a very bright future in Red.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous April 14, 2009 3:46 pm

quite fckn impressive. i thought the ospreys would challenge them at least. being mike phillips first thing i would have done after the game, have a look at that replay

y the hell is this whole nh vs sh discussion on again?

lets find this years lions, that would be way more an interesting discussion

· Reply · Report

welshbok April 14, 2009 4:19 pm

Notice Shane "I can't tackle for shit" Williams being his usual best on defence, running alongside herding like a sheepdog!

Most overrated winger in world rugby, just as useless as Brent Russel.

· Reply · Report

mattn April 14, 2009 4:27 pm

From what ive seen Keith Earls looks like a SERIOUS talent, for the past year (when i first heard of him) his all round game has developed very well, soon i can see him challenging for a place in the Irish squad deffinatley.

· Reply · Report

7drunkennights April 14, 2009 4:32 pm

its a pity this video didnt show warwicks impressive 2nd drop kick from the half way line.
There was also a funny moment when the munster fans were singing the black velvet band. This was in response to Tommy Bowes rendition of the song on irelands grand slam homecoming. Apparently he clapped to the crowd and was smiling when it happened.

· Reply · Report

WOWMUNSTER April 14, 2009 5:08 pm

munster are the best club side in the world at the moment (and I'm an aussie)
i cant see them been beaten any time soon!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous April 14, 2009 5:16 pm

I think Toulouse, Clermont and Stade Franais can beat them :)

· Reply · Report

Steve April 14, 2009 5:21 pm

Ok name and shame yourself first comment.
You called NH rugby 'tennis', have you watched any S14? There is just as much kicking, its the ELV's that caused it, and any pundit will agree with that.
And you said that Munster would lose to the SA teams, have you seen these teams play? The only ones I rate are the Bulls and they aren't anything special this season. Munster have the best pack for any club, its full of internationals, and aswell as this we have the two Irish scrum halves, the out-half, rugbys next O'Driscoll in cetre, Doug Howlett and a second string team that has been racking up wins for fun while the internationals where away.
Can the SA teams or even any S14 team boast that?
The NZ game proves it!

· Reply · Report

KeithEarlsHas2FirstN April 14, 2009 5:40 pm

I think O'Gara just plays better for Munster than he does for Ireland. It's not that he tries to or anything, it's just how it seems to work out.

Also, Stringer may be small, be he's a much faster at getting the ball out than O'Leary...which makes for an exciting game where they rack up some 40+ points.

Anyways, this was a great game! Thanks for posting, RD.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous April 14, 2009 5:43 pm

Sonny parker was the only good ospreys player.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous April 14, 2009 6:18 pm

FrankyH > So the World Cup Final between the golden years of South Africa vs the old hasbeens of England was a huge flair induced whitewash by a huge point margin?

Parp, wrong.

The HEC is knockout rugby, the Super 14, isn't.

· Reply · Report

arleyhill April 14, 2009 6:32 pm

munster r gud but not the finished article yet, the ospreys r a team in decline and cardiff or leicester will compete 100% better at the breakdown, in defence and attack then the o's did allowing munster quick ball to throw it around, with a lack of control at times, face it ospreys were shit.

tigers 4 the cup

· Reply · Report

Dune April 14, 2009 6:38 pm

Madflyhalf, from what I saw of the highlights of the Blues v Toulouse game, Martyn Williams was in pretty good form, so I would say that there still more than one name in the hat.

I think this game proves that the Ospreys need to get their act together, especially in the coaching department, because they have a talented squad of players to chose from. Quibbling about selection after such a massive defeat is a bit pointless, but I don't understand why they continue to select Vaughton, in this game they could have chosen a back three of 11. Shane, 15. Spratt and 14. Bowe. Unless Spratt was injured, which it says nowhere on the Ospreys site.

Anyway, congrats to Munster, they are looking pretty good for the final, but this is a tough competition and all is still to play for.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous April 14, 2009 6:40 pm

"But it's a known fact that Ospreys are pretenders."

They've won the Magners twice reached the EDF final twice in a row winning it once and the quarter finals of the HEC twice in a row.

Oh and they were only formed in 2003, something people like to forget when they talk about how the Ospreys have achieved nothing.

· Reply · Report

Third Centre April 14, 2009 6:45 pm

Munster are going to destroy Leinster.


· Reply · Report

Madflyhalf April 14, 2009 7:16 pm

@ Dune:
Yes, Martyn Williams is the only other name, but he usually shows best in defence rather in attack (probably due to his age eheh..).

IMO Wallace is more allround player!

Wallace now is often shifted @ n8, for he's extremely fast and he's got good hands, that allow Munster to take advantage immediatly from the new offside line @5m... it seems the shifting done by Rassie Erasmus with Luke Watson the last year, during the first ELVs trial

I love Wallace, he's the best openside in Europe, even better than Bergamasco, cause he's more disciplinated! - and I'm Italian! XD

· Reply · Report

Madflyhalf April 14, 2009 7:26 pm

any chances to see again munster's pack tackle on ryan jones after a scrum in the first half??

O_o massive!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous April 14, 2009 7:54 pm

Munster would crush any team in the world no problem. Face it SH none of your teams could stand up to them simple as.
Keith Earls has unbelievable pace!!!
he kicked philips' ass on that sprint and phillips had 10 yards on him too. Earls should go on the lions tour this year and let him play in the mid wek team.

· Reply · Report

Eoghan April 14, 2009 8:17 pm

Munster - awesome & well done. Definitely question marks on the Mafi offload but borderline...Earls' second try I think the reply shows his knee clipped the white wash before Phillips lifted his legs...but simply awesome & comprehensive rugby.

I'll be at Croke Park cheering for Leinster but in hope of a good occasion more than in realistic expectation of us upsetting Munster.

· Reply · Report

jamestheconvict April 14, 2009 8:30 pm

metronomic, metronomic - ha ha ha ha ah aha

· Reply · Report

jamestheconvict April 14, 2009 8:31 pm

"Munster are obscenely good at the moment. The only Super 14 team I could see beating them at the
moment is the Crusaders"

are you serious ??

and who is paul warwick ? seriously....

· Reply · Report

Jochen April 14, 2009 8:42 pm

They have to play at least two games to win the HC. Three of the quarterfinals were so close, so everybody has to be on form in the semis

· Reply · Report

brian April 14, 2009 9:13 pm

Munster is very impressive since beginning of 2009

Because of toulouse defeat, i don't see who can beat them.

I just wish they will continue this kind of game rather their traditional rolling mauls..

· Reply · Report

Gav April 14, 2009 9:15 pm

Jochen is correct, as a Munster man I am very aware that there are 4 teams left in the competition any of which could win it and would deserve to do so.

Ospreys had a bad day at the office - I hope they get the back office sorted out and come back strong next year.

· Reply · Report

old fart April 14, 2009 9:15 pm

That Ospreys team was a very strong team.
Great penetration in attack numbers at ruck, great defense too.
If Munster can beat Ospreys at home they can definitely go to Croke Park and get a result against the ladyboys, even with O'Driscoll, Fitzgerald and Van der Linde back.
And then a handy one in Edinburgh against those Leicester softies in the final.
It's all a bit easy isn't it.
They should probably just call the competition off and award Munster the trophy again.
Declare it a walkover on the emphatic victory on Sunday;)

· Reply · Report

richie April 14, 2009 9:26 pm


Paul Warwick is an Australian out-half currently playing with Munster. He originally came to Ireland a few years ago and played with Connacht. He was signed from Connacht last season and has now established himself as the starting Full-back in Munster's team. As you can see from the video he's making a very big impact for us. He has also represented Australia at 7s level.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous April 14, 2009 10:21 pm

Cdn content

Mafi has to be the best centre in the world right now. Incredible defence, hard, elusive running, superb distribution and sublime skills. Did anyone else note the pick up with one hand off the ground? Superb skills to do so during such a fast paced game! Would love to see Munster play the S14 champs. They do benefit from the SH backs, but their pack is en par with any club side world wide.

· Reply · Report

Hendrick April 14, 2009 10:47 pm

Amazing not the actual game, but the fact this game was on U.S television on a ESPN in real time. There are actually starting to take notice of rugby in the states. I was shock to find it on the tv at my work, and the great part was everybody at my work started asking me question about the game and seem to be enjoying it.

· Reply · Report

TheWeasel April 14, 2009 10:48 pm

Hardly the best ospreys team
i have no idea how vaughton is playing for the ospreys, theres better wingers in the welsh premiership!!
paul james is a joke, he brings nothing to the team
Munster won well but to a poor depleted ospreys team, they shouldnt get carried away.

· Reply · Report

mark April 14, 2009 10:59 pm

i'd love to see munster play some of the SH teams,i think it'd be really close.what munster do best is control games,so it'd be interesting to see if they could control the physicality and pace of a SH team.munster are poor when they can't control,like against ulster recently.

and anonymous who left the first comment and later said "the only reason they won is because O'Gara was kicking everything he put his hands on".O'Gara barely kicked at all.i was at the game too and also read in the paper that other than penalties he didn't kick until almost the 40th minute,so you're just talking a load of shit

· Reply · Report

Anonymous April 14, 2009 11:44 pm

The clip left out probably the best moment of the game: Warwick's second drop goal.

· Reply · Report

Brennie April 15, 2009 12:51 am

Pepper spray lol !
Baaad commentary

Good perf by Munster

· Reply · Report

AmerikaLock April 15, 2009 1:01 am

Love how quiet it gets a For kicks, classic Munster

· Reply · Report

Anonymous April 15, 2009 4:27 am

that earls try where the no:9 tackled him was def out.

compare that to englands disallowed try at rwc07 - wtf indeed.

· Reply · Report

Billy Bob April 15, 2009 6:22 am

"that earls try where the no:9 tackled him was def out.

compare that to englands disallowed try at rwc07 - wtf indeed." it to Shane William's try against Scotland in the 08 Six Nations...Williams was clearly out in that one and it was awarded; Earls was maybe out - but maybe not - in this one. I think it's amazing how there were so many opportunities for a part of his body to go over the touchline, but he seemed to lift his foot, knee, etc. up at exactly the right time...crazy stuff.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous April 15, 2009 11:44 am

Yeah O'Connells Try and Warwicks's amazing second DG were left ouit, but on the whole, a great clip.

· Reply · Report

Paddy April 15, 2009 12:11 pm

an amazin tackle by philips on earls but if philips hadnt lifted earls legs up at the end he would of been out. very unlucky. cant see anyone beatin munster this season.

· Reply · Report

Paddy April 15, 2009 12:12 pm

at the heineken cup I mean :P

· Reply · Report

Anonymous April 15, 2009 9:16 pm

What is this talk of SH vs NH? The fact is, teams like Toulouse, Munster, Clermont etc. are good enough to beat any Super 14 team, and the better Super 14 teams could beat them as well. But for whoever is saying that the SH are shit at rugby, that is just ludicrous. They're a cut above the Six Nations teams in general, although it'd be interesting to see Ireland play them now that they've won the Grand Slam and been revolutionised. France, England, Ireland and Wales though when on good form can beat the Tri-Nations, no question about it.

· Reply · Report

limericklegend April 15, 2009 10:12 pm

earls is the perfect man to fill drico's boots when he retires...i have no doubht keith earls is going down to SA on th lions tour..

quality act true munster man aswell

· Reply · Report

Anonymous April 15, 2009 10:16 pm

what age is earls??? i heard he was like 28....or is the warrick??

· Reply · Report

Eoghan April 16, 2009 12:57 am

Warrick is 28 - earls is a good bit younger...21 I think.

· Reply · Report

geraint April 16, 2009 8:47 am

Said to my dad before the game that munster would put 40 points on them. The only reason that ospreys win any games at all is through individual brilliance. As a team, they are the worst professional side in wales. I watch my local semi-pro side pontypridd and we play as more of a team than ospreys.
Munster as much as i'm fed up to say it are brilliant, would like to see leinster beat them just so there's a chance of someone else winning it. So to put it simply...munster are brilliant, ospreys are extremely overrated and have been for years. Quite glad to see them get a pasting so that hopefully their coaches can finally bugger off elsewhere.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous April 17, 2009 9:07 pm

brian said munster have been good since 2009

wat about 2 HC's?, a neat win versus all blacks and magners league sucess ye good since 2009

· Reply · Report

Ruthy Walsh April 17, 2009 9:11 pm

Does anyone have that clip when the Munster crowd sang 'Black Velvet Band' to Tommy Bowe during the Ospreys match??:D

· Reply · Report

Anonymous April 19, 2009 8:33 pm

Pff, the ospreys are awful atm, with their arrogance, lack of decent coaching and injury list.
They we're neving going to beat a great team like munster with those 3 problems.

I'm going to stick with the Blues to win the Heineken though,
Leciester will be a tough game for us, but we've beaten them in the EDF at home, and that wasn't in the big arms park either.
As for the other Semi, i think it'll be a Munster win, and a good final..

Munster definately have the star studded team with their huge irish pack and SH backs, but my heart says the blues.

· Reply · Report

Commenting as Guest | Register or Login

All comments are moderated and will be removed immediately if offensive.