Eddie Butler on Jonny Wilkinson career


Ma'afu banned for punch on Tom Youngs


Tameifuna's huge hit on Michael Hooper


Biggest punches & worst fights in France


Toulon do the double with Top 14 win


Huge hit by Tonga in Pacific Nations Cup


Two casual tryscorers shown up


5 Biggest Hits of the Premiership season


Tony Brown takes big hit from Pakalani

Saturday, August 08, 2009

Springboks beat the Wallabies at Newlands

Springboks beat the Wallabies at Newlands

South Africa continued their good run of form with another Tri Nations win, this time against the Wallabies in Cape Town. They strengthened their grip on the tournament with the 29-17 victory over the tourists.

The third win in a row for them in this years tournament, they've now won all their home matches, which is imperative if you aim to stand a chance of taking the title.

Morne Steyn once again stepped up as he kicked 24 points with seven penalties and a drop goal. The Wallabies took an early lead from an excellent second minute converted try to Adam Ashley-Cooper, but the home side then came back and took control through the boot of Steyn.

A Berrick Barnes left footed dropkick halted the Boks' progress momentarily, but then Steyn kicked a drop of his own, followed by Victor Matfield scoring from a neat kick ahead from captain John Smit.

Matt Giteau was sinbinned for a reckless challenge on Fourie Du Preez, followed by Richard Brown going off for a professional foul, shortly after that. The Springboks went into the break 23-10 up, with 15 men against 13.

Steyn kept slotting them after the break, but Giteau came back and scored a fantastic individual effort, giving the Wallabies hope as they looked to make a comback.

George Smith was carded too, for a cynical bit of play that clearly came from frustration, and Steyn slotted his final penalty two minutes from time, sealing the comfortable win for the Boks.

South Africa now lead the table with 12 points, followed by New Zealand on four, and Australia, having played a game less, on one.


Time: 09:11

Posted at 7:38 pm | 125 comments

Viewing 125 comments

doyler8 August 08, 2009 7:45 pm

first...brussow continues to impress and was once again immense at the breakdown!! Credit is due to James O'Connor who's been given a bit of abuse on rugbydump recently...his counter attacking 2day was suburb and always looked dangerous with ball in hand and he was also solid under a high ball!!

overall an enjoyable game to watch!

· Reply · Report

bigox August 08, 2009 7:45 pm

Brussouw. Phenomenal. 'nuff said

1 or 2 weeks for giteau?

· Reply · Report

Huh!! the 3rd August 08, 2009 8:37 pm

After RD giving him such a warm up with tribute, bar the try, I can't remember Giteau having such a poor game. Agree with 'bigox'. Barnes had a good game and had assumed 1st reciever role before Giteau went to the bin.

Disapointed with Australia, SA did deserve to win, but they didn't need to get out of 2nd gear.

SA have 3N nearly wrapped up. 1 win or even 3 loses with 3/4 bonus points and its theirs. Unless, Aus and NZ have some big wins against eachother, which in any case may help SA.

I can see SA beating Aus at least once away and maybe even sneaking it against NZ, they're that poor (honestly, when was the last time NZ had played 6 lost 3). Though Carter had good game for Canterbury and came through some heavy punishment.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 08, 2009 8:45 pm

james o connor impresses me each time i see him.

as for giteua's sin binning deserving a citing ARE YOU ******* SERIOUS?!

this is rugby, a contact game. he was originally going for the ball, saw the man in front of him and instinstictively/stupidly jumped into him in defence. if its a citing then i truly wonder what this world is coming to.

.....and this is coming from an englishman

· Reply · Report

JuiCe August 08, 2009 9:06 pm

To Ano above, m8 are you blind? he didnt even look for the ball he went strait for the player. please go and watch it again then you will see he wasnt even going for the ball!

· Reply · Report

Dan The Man August 08, 2009 9:07 pm

im not even guna say anything...

...just that it wasnt even close so pls dont try and analyze this one pls...

brussow OR steyn is the player of the tournament..."finish and klaar"

· Reply · Report

Cheis August 08, 2009 9:41 pm

brussow was great!

wallabies made life hard for themselfs: couple of silly yellow cards and so many penalties

i'm not complaining though ;) !! BOKKE!!

· Reply · Report

creggs08 August 08, 2009 10:55 pm

to anon above!

are you serious Brussow has been player of the tournament so far!!

never have i seen such a serious player at the break down!!

the only player who can destroy McCaw in the world right now is brussow!!

and for burger....if i were him id be shitting myself....how is he meant to get on the squad even when youve got brussow russow and smith...all of them way better than burger to!!

· Reply · Report

T August 08, 2009 11:34 pm

Brussow = Master of the turn over.

And what about Steyn? The effect he has on the team is immense. They are so calm. Anytime SA concede a try or penalty, everyone just goes, "So what? We've got Steyn." He is gonna kick them to victory.

Bok for the Tri-Nations.

· Reply · Report

Andrew August 08, 2009 11:39 pm

Matt Giteau deserved a red card.
Whats wrong Aussies, South Africa to strong that you got to resort to illegal tactics to try and beat the BOKKE

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 08, 2009 11:54 pm

I see there are more opinions about the cards. I didn't get to see the game but - who was the ref?
Thanks

· Reply · Report

Hendrick August 09, 2009 12:24 am

Aus is officially the worst in the Tri-Nations. The performance they had last night was pretty bad.
They had to many turn overs, and never look dangerous.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 1:53 am

as a person who hates mccaw with all his heart, and i seriously just mean unparalled hatred. i believe that mccaw is better than brussow on his day, mccaw isnt even match fit yet and is too busy leading a broken side to play his own game. dont get me wrong brussow is good, but DEFINITELY not better than mccaw. go SA. :)

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 3:20 am

ref wasnt to bad either

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 4:23 am

I haven't watched the whole game yet. But.................... regardless of your Tri-nations loyalty, Giteau is not known to be a dirty player. I think the Adrenaline of the rushing for the High ball made him commit that error. It was unprofessional. Something I would expect from Burger,the Old Rocky Elsom and Jerry Collins. Once again I named the Tri-Nations bad-boys. Bakkies is a bitch! His lesson is coming. I group Giteau with Carter and the likes of Muliaina when it comes to Sportsmanship. They have rare occurences. Let's forgive Giteau!

· Reply · Report

vinniechan August 09, 2009 4:57 am

Brussow makes me appreciate a hard grinding blindside like never before, cox he's the type to clean those f**kers out from every single ruck.
As a neutral spectator, the Boks with Piennar is more exciting to watch, but with a pack like that it's hard to drop someone like M Styen who bag all the 3 pointers

· Reply · Report

vinniechan August 09, 2009 5:01 am

As for the binning of Giteau I don't think the intent was anything malicious.
But then he completely misjudged his run and he was not any position to contend for the ball, which made it looked so reckless so he did bring it upon himself

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 5:10 am

Brussow,Brussow and nothing else.... If the ALL Blacks had Jerry Collins, he could have dealt with him, they have not replaced Jerry Collins and never will

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 5:16 am

I don't like the comparison between McCaw and Brussow.
McCaw is arguably the most all rounded rugby player in the world - if the situation needs him to be a ball carrier, he will grind the hard yards, if he needs to play with the backs, he will keep the back line going.
Brussow is a specialist in the break down, and Springboks can afford the luxury of having him because they have the most powerful pack in the world - if you cannot bring down the ball carrier, there's nothing to fetch.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 7:26 am

Agree with anon above, McCaw is such an all round player. It's injustice to compare Brussow to him.
Brussow needs to do more than create turnovers to be mentioned in the same league as McCaw

· Reply · Report

sebastian August 09, 2009 9:30 am

wtf was giteau on ?

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 9:50 am

hahaha well said to the man above!!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 10:03 am

Jesus Christ the amount of penalties in these test matches these days are disgusting to watch.

· Reply · Report

creggs08 August 09, 2009 10:11 am

i lol'd at peterson=D

· Reply · Report

Ozzy August 09, 2009 10:48 am

SA are turning into the Pomms - ie playing BORING Rugby. The only way they can get their points is from the boot, just like England.

· Reply · Report

Chris G August 09, 2009 11:19 am

Lot of bitter losers on here. Man up, South Africa deserved it. From an Englishman.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 11:20 am

Sounds like sour grapes. Stop being so jealous of how good the Boks are. Boring rugby? please. The reason why they couldn't score tries was due to the Australians spoiling tactics, hence the penalties and yellow cards. The Boks are playing Bulls rugby and once they click, you will see scores like that of the super 14 final.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 11:23 am

How amusing that the South Africans go all up in arms at Giteau's actions. The Saffers have long been regarded as the dirtiest nation to play against (Corne Krige, Robbie Fleck, Burger) yet they can't deal with anyone doing anything to their beloved Bokke. Not saying it shouldn't have been a yellow I just love the commentators reaction. A good game to watch but must say I find SA very boring to watch, no ambition or flair. Their game plan is based on the Steyns kicking the ball as far as they can, Matfield and Botha contesting the line out and then maybe, just maybe when they get to the oppo's 22 they'll try and score. otherwise, just give it Morne or Francois and go for a droppy.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 11:33 am

To the anon ass above - @ 11:49

BOKS - WORLD CHAMPS
BOKS - WON ALL AI'S LAST YEAR (RECORD SCORE AGAINST ENG COMES TO MIND...)
BOKS - LIONS CHAMPS
BOKS - BEAT AB'S 2X
BOKS - BEAT OZ
AND WE STILL HAVEN'T EVEN BEEN CHALLENGED YET... and we haven't even played at our true potential ...Hmmmm - jealous maybe - thought so!!!!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 11:36 am

THe only reason you hate our players, team etc - IS BECAUSE WE ARE JUST TOOOOOOO DAMN GOOD & YOU KNOW IT. call us dirty, blah, blah blah boring blah blah blah.... call us what you like BUT - WE ARE WORLD CHAMPS and don't give a damn what everyone else says -YOU CAN ONLY DREAM THAT YOUR TEAM WILL HAVE A FORWARD PACK LIKE OURS SOMEDAY - I SAY - KEEP DREAMING AND WE WILL WIN ALL THE CUPS UNDER THE SUN!!!!!!!!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 11:37 am

I agree with the anon above!!! Well said! GO BOKKE - WIN THE 3N!!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 11:38 am

BRUSSOW - what a player! And those complaining about comparing him to mccaw - I agree - how can you compare them - brussow is MUCH younger and this is only like his 4/5 test??? HE IS ONLY GANNA GET BETTER!!!!!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 11:41 am

Can't take these Northern hemisphere refs - get them outta the 3n!!!!!!!!!!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 11:44 am

From a neutral fan - the aussies played such spoiling, negative rugby to try to stop the boks from scoring tries - and as the boks are such a professional side they took the 3 points, nothing wrong with that. giteau should have been given a RED CARD, no intention to go for the ball at all!!!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 11:48 am

BOKS - 12
KIWIS - 4
OZ - 1
ENOUGH SAID!!!!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 11:49 am

Does anyone know who the boks are playing in the AI's??? I would love to go and see them play - good forward play!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 11:49 am

Just last week i heard some Bok commentators saying the JP Peterson is the best cover defender in the world. But that was one of the worst attempts of a tackle ive seen in a long time.

Id have to say O Driscoll is the best all rounder in the world. He is dynamite in offense as seen all season long and he grinds hards yards like a forward too eg. the two winning tries he scored against england and wales in the six nations. He drops goals aswell. He is the best centre in the world at getting in rucks and turning over ball easily.

I think that the Boks will have a real tough time at beating Ireland in the autumn series. Ireland and South Africa are the two teams in form in the world and i think that is gonna be tha game of the year.

Aussie living in France

· Reply · Report

Kev August 09, 2009 11:49 am

Can someone remind me of the structure of the tournament please? Everyone plays everyone else twice? Is that right? And why did NZ play SA away twice in a row?

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 11:52 am

MATFIELD - AMAZING , truly amazing - I think the boks grabbed approx 8 of the ozzies lineouts!!! 8 and this is internationl rugger!!!!! WOW, boks are red-hot!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 11:56 am

Aussie living in france , the SA commentator said JP was ONE of the best cover defence in the world, not THE best!!!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 12:17 pm

Don't you dare compare the Boks to Ireland, a team that has never, ever beaten NZ.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 12:26 pm

Commentator "this is an Aussie team for the future". LOL
Umm....like....Shouldn't they be fielding a team for the present day.

Who's the SA sponge girl?

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 12:29 pm

That morne guy is just too cool and calm - damn I hate him!!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 12:30 pm

If ireland played NZ today they would get hammered easily. Theres something not right with them right now and ireland are in a great place right now i gotta say. Some of the best players in the world in their position are from ireland

· Reply · Report

Kearney for tests August 09, 2009 12:31 pm

Yeah I agree with anonymous above. Saying SA are in the same league as Ireland is an outrage. Ireland beat them senseless the last time they played.
Anyway, is anyone else sick of how cocky all these South Africans are now? At least when New Zealand were the big team in rugby they didn't go around pointing it out to everyone and insulting everyone else and claiming that the team aren't even playing well, and that every other team is shit. And claiming that Steyn is the best outhalf in the world and the player of the year is simply folly. He kicks goals and that's it.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 12:51 pm

kearney for tests - temper temper! Who said steyn is the best??? As for NZ never saying that they are the best in the world when they were no. 1 - maybe because they never won a world cup when they were no.1???? Anyway - why can't we say we are WORLD CHAMPS AND NO 1 - when that is EXACTLY what we are??? IF ierland ever become world champs or no. 1 - I'm sure you would be the first to yell it out to the world!!!!!! And until then - don't compare the BOKS to ierland - cause you ganna come up short in that argument mate!!! Now go and have a beer and see if you can chill and wait until the next world cup to see what ireland can do!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 12:52 pm

So saying that the BOKS are WORLD CHAMPS AND NO.1 - is cocky - hmmm i thought it was a FACT!!!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 12:55 pm

Hahahahaha - loved that grubber by smit (from a forward fan!) That's why I love this game - anything is possible!!!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 12:58 pm

love the way the irish only want to have a shot at us kiwis when we aren't on top of our game ...what does that say about irish rugby...???

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 1:01 pm

Bladdy brussow!!! Just too damn good AGAIN!

· Reply · Report

Nico August 09, 2009 1:02 pm

Credit to SA for winning the game. Disappointed by Australia. And bored to death by this game Habana must play solitaire on his wing... Reminds me of England in 2003. Unfortunately - to me, it's one way of winning games. To one to enthuse the kids, though, and get them to play this sport we love. But fair on the Booke for winning it all.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 1:02 pm

Moment of the match - SMITS grubber!!! HAHAHAHAHAHA!!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 1:09 pm

"I don't think the South Africans are getting as much credit as they deserve' (quote by Dan Carter)

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 1:10 pm

All those slating SA - wait till the AI's .... GO BOKKE!!!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 1:12 pm

Well played Boks, from a kiwi fan. You are playing powerful rugger at the mo!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 1:15 pm

I'm starting to think, what pack is ever going to dominate this SA bunch????

· Reply · Report

themull August 09, 2009 2:41 pm

SA pretty much have the tri nations wrapped up at this stage.....Aus and NZ basically only playing for second place now....

Looking forward to the Autumn Internationals..
Eng vs Australia
Wales vs new Zealand
FRance vs South Africa (prob best of the lot)
Ireland vs South Africa (another great game)
and Wales Australia

Should be very good series of games....

· Reply · Report

FrankyH August 09, 2009 2:42 pm

Sour grapes is poor. Gloating isn't much better, but at least it's earned. Winning feels damn good, especially after beating the number 2 & 3 teams in the world. SA are entitled to enjoy it.

Ripping into their style of winning screams of immaturity.

They put extreme pressure on the other sides, win penalties, then slot them. Nothing wrong with that. If rugby were all about flair, Fiji would be the number 1 team in the world.

Well done Boks. That Aussie side have one of the most potent backlines in the world, and they were cut down from performing, bar the 2nd minute try.

· Reply · Report

Mr Bokke August 09, 2009 2:53 pm

BOKKE BOKKE BOKKE, BOK BOK BOK. BOKE, BOK, BOKKE, BOK. BOKKE BOKKE BOKKE, BOK BOK BOK!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 3:13 pm

Well played SA - can't argue with a team who's just put away the no 2 & 3 side teams in the world. Can't wait to see this Bok side fire on all cylindars.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 3:14 pm

WHAT A GRUBBER BY SMIT!!! LOVE IT!!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 3:17 pm

Brussow, brussow, brussow!

· Reply · Report

luxi August 09, 2009 3:41 pm

habana's dive into the aussie forwards at the kickoff is pointless but bloody funny...xD

· Reply · Report

David August 09, 2009 3:58 pm

This Brussow really is going from strength to strength, he wasn't quite so effective when he came up against Martyn Williams though :D

Unlucky Wallabies, well played Boks!
Steyn is such a good player.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 4:04 pm

Anyone else scared of what this bok side is capable of when they actually start to use their backs... I think they are just going to go for the one away win in aus and nz to secure the 3n and then we may see them use the likes of habana and Jacque fourie more often..scary if you think about it. Just don't think we will see it until they have the 3N trophy! (and this from a neutral fan)

· Reply · Report

luxi August 09, 2009 4:04 pm

giteau's intention is clearly to smash into dupreez, his eyes never get close to the ball

he deserves min. 2weeks, but who knows what citing commisionner will say cos of all the recent mis-citings-bans

-burger eye-gouge shuld have had min 3months

-b.botha at the breakdown didnt deserve ban

-sergio parisse "eye-gouge" 8weeks but its actually an accidental contact between the italians hand, and the nz's cheek...)

if gits is banned i reckon, deans'll move barnes up to 10 and quade cooper at 12 ( eventough i would have cooper at 10 and barnes at 12, like they do for the reds, cos they are probably more used to it)

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 4:05 pm

Steyn is a match winner - so calm and unfazed...

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 4:07 pm

M Steyn = pure class, what a dropgoal!

· Reply · Report

RevKev August 09, 2009 4:13 pm

Matt Giteau should not be representing Australia no matter how good he might be as a no10 - that deliberate elbow to the face of a worthy oponent deminishes the skill and guts of our team - he wasn't even looking for the ball, never mind competing for it! Matt Giteau was a flyhalf with great potential who stuffed it up with a complete lack of discipline.

· Reply · Report

Flanker August 09, 2009 4:19 pm

look at habana after the kickoff he starts to run, gets smashed against an aussie and then he slaps in the middle of the ruck!!!
epic!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 4:20 pm

I've never seen the ozzies so rattled & ill-disciplined. The boks made both the ozzies and kiwi's crack, forcing these two top teams to make so many errors and backchat the ref and give away so many penalties & cards...hmmm looks like if you can't beat them you gana try ANYTHING...

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 4:23 pm

LOL @ habana at kickoff!! Bwhahahaahahahaha!! Good stuff!

· Reply · Report

Mike August 09, 2009 4:32 pm

Brussow is awesome.

About a month ago, everyone was wondering if Steyn should be the flyhalf or not. It seems clear now that he's the man for the job. He's doing what Dan Carter did for the AB's a few years ago - scoring and/or setting up all their points.

Giteau is going to have to take the heat for what he did. Not going for the ball. He figured he'd try to time it perfectly and if he missed, oh well, at least he'd get to take somebody out. He could be looking at a couple weeks for that one.

The Tri-Nations is South Africa's to lose. We'll see what the AB's can do against them in NZ, but SA's got it all together right now.

www.realrugby.com

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 4:50 pm

What's with all the commonwealth guys and fauxhawks? They look like ankle grabbers.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 5:51 pm

'SA are turning into the Pomms - ie playing BORING Rugby. The only way they can get their points is from the boot, just like England.'

theyve won all their games comfortably. who cares where points come from, its a win. other teams have to concede penalties for the bokks to take the 3 points so Aus can only be looking at themselves. if they concede penalties to stop tries then that is a credit to the SA teams

· Reply · Report

Ben August 09, 2009 6:46 pm

man I hate M.Steyn, because he is just too damn good.

I kinda felt bad for Giteau, he is just definitely not in his character that day and his perfomance reminded me of nothing that resembles his attitude at the game of rugby.

· Reply · Report

bod is GOD August 09, 2009 6:47 pm

that habana run is the funniest thing ive seen in a while!

· Reply · Report

Boz August 09, 2009 7:10 pm

McCaw vs/ Brussow

Brussow reminds me of exactly what McCaw was when he first came on the scene. He is an unrelenting pursuer of the ball.

McCaw has not always been well rounded. He grew into that role. However, his breakdown ability has also diminished significantly. When you play the style of 'fetcher' that the two of them play, your body takes a pounding and players always have trouble sustaining that level of play.

McCaw may be more well rounded now, but I would trade the McCaw that runs, tackles, passes, and kicks for the one that just flies around winning ball.

McCaw may be a 'better player' due to his well roundedness, but Brussow is infinitely more valuable right now.

· Reply · Report

cp85 August 09, 2009 8:47 pm

to anonymouse above:
'Can't take these Northern hemisphere refs - get them outta the 3n!!!!!!!!!!'

We invented the game,we should know the rules. See what the super 14 ELV's did, boooring. Look how Boks are using the rolling maul now.

About the game, moment of madness from Giteau, will get cited no doubt. Boks win again, no surprise really, australia didn't challenge and were outplayed in places. Very solid in the scrum though.

For me, Beast and Habana are overrated. Brussouw, Matfield and Steyne were awesome, they are the real game changers. Bok forwards, incredible at the breakdown and strong throughout. Game was won there.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 9:38 pm

Penalty fest. How boring. No wonder League is more popular in Australia.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 10:02 pm

Is anyone else bored with teams kicking penalties? Also have you ever noticed that the best team in the world just has the most on-form 10 with a set of decent forwards? It used to be England with Wilkinson, now it's SA with Steyn. Fair enough if it works, but it's boring as hell!

· Reply · Report

G August 09, 2009 11:34 pm

How boring...

· Reply · Report

Jon August 09, 2009 11:40 pm

Too many penalties, too many cards.
Typical NH ref.
Well done Boks, best team in the world at the moment.
For the Irish - you've gotta be joking if you think your team would have a chance against the Boks away from home. Living in a fantasy world.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 11:41 pm

I don't know why people are saying that the SA pack will never be dominated.. The lions if I recall done them in pretty good. Yeah the beast got Vickery in the fist half on the test, but Adam Jones changed that and Vickery stepped back up and think the Lions pack had that better of them in the overall series.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 09, 2009 11:46 pm

yeah i agree to comment above!!! lets be honest, the boks scraped the win in the first and second test, like winning it in the last 5 minutes both times, also when the lions players were all going off with injuries.. showed in the third test when the lions utterly dominated the boks and got a bigger winning margin in that last test than the boks did with the 2 combined.

· Reply · Report

Andrew August 10, 2009 1:12 am

To anon above:

yah, you're totally right. the lions winning margin in the third (and totally meaningless) test is a clear indication that the boks aren't as great as everyone says they are. let's be honest, if the boks hadn't been resting many of their better players in that third test they wouldn't have beaten the all blacks and wallabies on three consecutive weekends. if they were any good they would have white-washed the lions in three straight tests then scored bonus points wins in each of their first three tri-nations games.
i mean get a grip people, 5 wins out of 6 against the best 3 teams in the world (including two over a combined side from 4 nations) over the course of 2 months is nothing to get excited about. it happens all the time! stop overrating these boks!

· Reply · Report

cheyanqui August 10, 2009 1:19 am

Giteau has a very good disciplinary record. That aside, if the citing commissioner simply looks at the video, it shows he has his head down, and does not look for the ball. On that alone, it deserves a suspension.

Whatever the guidelines are [for charging into a player in the air], there is a band with a top end and bottom end of time to serve the suspension.

Giteau deserves to sit at least one game. And if he gets only one, it's because he's a clean player to date, and thus on the low end of the suspension.

When guys like Botha and Burger get suspended, many SA fans have a knee-jerk reaction.

The reality is that the IRB has entire file cabinets with citings for these guys. Thus, when they are found guilty, the suspension invariably ends up at the top end of the guidelines.

On another note, I was disappointed to not see the Boks able to convert more points during the 2-man bin. It looked like the Boks got too crazy with the ball and tried to open it up just a little too much.

Highlights for me:
1. Smit's chip kick, finished up by Victor Matfield
2. Brussouw. As a 1.78M backrow, I love seeing someone bring his aspects to the game.

Burger is a solid player, but he plays the typical direct, Boer rugby -- notice how he runs at defenders? He's out to make a statement, not to open up play. That to me is more of a blind side's play. Leave Broussow at the open side fetcher role. Put Juan Smith on the bench and make him an impact sub, or have he and Burger fight for the #7 (blind side) jersey.

· Reply · Report

Doyler August 10, 2009 1:20 am

"Don't you dare compare the Boks to Ireland, a team that has never, ever beaten NZ."
Yeah it was just one of our provinces that beat the all blacks.

And to Jon above, blaming the ref will get you nowhere. Do you genuinely think the aussies were disciplined?
The Irish are not saying they would beat SA away from home, just that we can't wait to have a crack at them in the Autumn.

· Reply · Report

Jordan August 10, 2009 2:40 am

quite entertaining game. i have to be honest though morne steyn scoring a majority of boks points is starting to get a bit annoying, hes a really good kicker but surely there is some more attacking flair? disgusted with giteau that was shocking, i had been supporting Aus from the first minute coz i wanted to see boks lose a home game to make things more interesting for when they tour, and watching james o'connor shine was a delight he is looking to be one of the great rising stars, pity mortlock left the field aswell i like to see him play. but yet again the man on form really is brussow, just seems to steal more and more ball every week. think we can see more of him for a long time to come. but not to burst bubbles to all the bok braggers on here (and dont say im a bad loser im a neutral here) its alright doing this at home, you show your real dynamite when your not on home turf.. keep your mouths shut incase it comes back to bite you on the away leg of the tour.

· Reply · Report

jon August 10, 2009 2:41 am

The Aussies weren't as bad as the ref seemed to think they were, just as the All Blacks weren't that bas the week before.
More relevant to what I was saying is the tendency for NH refs to reach for the whistle and the cards far too quickly and end up deciding test matches. They seem to think the crowd pays money to watch them.
It makes test matches frustrating and boring to watch.

· Reply · Report

Jordan August 10, 2009 2:47 am

just to add a bit more, i was also frustrated with Francois Steyn.. one steyn kicked everything, the other run all the time and waited till it was to late to look for a pass. a few time i was screaming at the tv coz i could see habana stood outside him.. seriously.. whos gonna make yards faster, steyn or habana? no contest. and Smit.. if morne ever got injured i think boks have a top class outside half there did you see that kick :L

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 10, 2009 3:20 am

The vid was 3 mins of highlights and 6 mins of kicking... thats why ELV's were introduced, to stop games like that. That said all credit to SA.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 10, 2009 3:20 am

The vid was 3 mins of highlights and 6 mins of kicking... thats why ELV's were introduced, to stop games like that. That said all credit to SA.

· Reply · Report

Lennox August 10, 2009 3:31 am

What a surprise, a NH ref hands out yellow cards like confetti and is easily influenced by a large partisan home crowd.
Get rid of NH refs from the 3-nations.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 10, 2009 3:54 am

I love the confected outrage about rough play from the south african commentators. Either they have absolutely no brains or are much wittier than I ever gave them credit for.

Du Preez went down quicker than a bucket of chicken at Os Du Rant's place. Come on man, you got the penalty, no need to milk it like an Italian soccer player!

SA are the best side going around at the moment. For the record.

Watching a "highlights" package of drop goals and penalty kicks is a waste of time. If the kicking was the highlight of the game for you then you're watching the wrong sport.

· Reply · Report

bigox August 10, 2009 5:20 am

giteau not cited? that is an outrage.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 10, 2009 7:23 am

STOP talking about how the bladdy lions were better than the boks, better forwards blah blah blah - if they were better - they would have won - ANYWAY - it is FOUR countries against ONE!!!!!!!! In all the 3n matches the Boks have never looked like losing!!! DEAL WITH IT !!!!!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 10, 2009 7:37 am

Can you imagine the reaction from a NH side if they won a series against a combined team from SA,NZ & OZ and then went on to beat the boks 2x in a row and NZ once....hmmmmm So to say that the SA fans are gloating and shouldn't until they travel is all bull.... any team could only dream of their success...let them enjoy it ( from a neutral fan)

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 10, 2009 7:38 am

I second that from the anon above. Give SA creadit, anyone who doesn't isn't a true rugby fan! Well done boks from a french fan, can't wait to meet you in Aug x

· Reply · Report

Timothy August 10, 2009 8:43 am

Go bokke, another win! We let them off the hook though, should have been a whipping!!

And the springboks are meant to be a dirty team????!!!! I would be disgraced by the likes of Giteau if I was a wallabies fan!

· Reply · Report

Timothy August 10, 2009 8:47 am

And by the way, I was at the game, the Giteau incident happened right in front of me, it was nothing but MALICIOUS! He claim he was jumping for the ball, he arrived way before the ball, and made no effort to catch it. He was trying to injure the best scrum half in world rugby.

As I said in my last post, I would be disgraced by the wallabies dirty performance!

· Reply · Report

creggs08 August 10, 2009 8:49 am

to lennox..

well of course a ref is going to hand out cards when

1. a player takes another player out without even looking for the ball!

2. a player comes from the wrong side of the ruck to do a professional foul to stop a forward movement!

how are these not cards??

mabye its noting to do with NH refs....mabye its SH teams getting away with so much crap over the years that when they actually face the law book they dont like it!!

· Reply · Report

Lennox August 10, 2009 8:54 am

Yeah, or maybe NH refs are pedantic and overeager to pull out cards and blow the whistle.
Lots of things could be considered a yellow card, it's subjective.
A good ref is very, very sparing with cards.
We've seen two test matches and six yellow cards, with two NH refs.
That's not a coincidence.
If you like pedantic officiating, fine, just keep your attention whore refs in Europe.

· Reply · Report

creggs08 August 10, 2009 9:09 am

so lennox are you saying that the ref should of gave giteau a slap on the wrist instead of a card?

if anything it should of been a straight red!!

and as for the flanker (cant remeber his name sorry) who got the 2nd yellow card...came in from the off-side picked teh ball up when on the ground then threw it away!

and this was after the ref spoke to both captains about the ruck!!

· Reply · Report

David August 10, 2009 9:35 am

"What a surprise, a NH ref hands out yellow cards like confetti and is easily influenced by a large partisan home crowd.
Get rid of NH refs from the 3-nations."

Lennox, norther hemisphere refs are pretty good actually, and i think its pathetic to blame the ref in the first place. In any case, they all make mistakes.

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 10, 2009 10:00 am

As a bok fan, I would like to urge some perspective on the issue of not citing Giteau.

Given the way Giteau landed - on his head - and the randomness of the citing process, we should be relieved Fourie du Preez was not cited for a spear tackle.

· Reply · Report

Gary August 10, 2009 10:34 am

the boks are good but its the breakdown and and kicker win it for them living off other teams mistakes not 2 much eye pleasing rugby

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 10, 2009 10:36 am

The boks will become a more complete team, give them time, it's the start of the season for them over there...

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 10, 2009 10:36 am

The boks are playing bulls rugby and we all know what happened in the S14 Final!!! GO BOKKE!

· Reply · Report

Andy August 10, 2009 10:53 am

Good game, enjoyed it. Giteau, what a muppet!!

Brussow is amazing, i'd have him ahead of Burger, he wins them so much ball.

Lennox, shut up you're an idiot.

· Reply · Report

Wessel August 10, 2009 1:00 pm

Bakkies gets a two week suspension for a common place clear out, and Gits does not even get cited.

And some people stil wonder why the Boks where justice arm bands?

· Reply · Report

Huh!! the 3rd August 10, 2009 2:06 pm

Maybe O'Gara should have been cited then, both clumsy and nothing more. I just don't understand Giteau's reasoning. He's 5'8 and challenging one of the best high ball fielders in the game. He was having a bad game and lost his composure for a couple of seconds.

On the SH fans moaning about the reffing. 3 yellows, all deserving as previous post points out. Had Smith and Brown not infringed, then SA may have scored tries, which I gather posters complain they're not doing, because opposition are illegally slowing down. If a ref blew for every single offence in the game, there'd be as many stoppages as American Football. I'm satisfied refs are finally clamping down on little offences like scrum feed, not binding and so on. They are after all trying to rid the sport of these mistakes for the long term betterment of the sport.

Finally as a neutral, as a winning team I don't think SA or their fans care that they're not entertaining. A win is a win. Yes we'd all like to see Habana receive 1st phase ball but I think he'll take winning over not scoring tries any day. Yes I'm Irish, not blinkered, like some on here, hopefully. I find it hard to take that we haven't beaten NZ in 104 years, 0 wins, 1 draw, 23 defeats. All some Irish suggest here is that its a pity we don't play NZ and SA more. We catch NZ when they are on a roll and it can be frustrating. However, I can't wait for Ire v SA in Nov. We have only played twice in last 5 seasons. Very poor organisation from an Ire pov. I would love if we played all 3N every year. Granted we'd lose alot but be better for it in the end.

· Reply · Report

Robert August 10, 2009 4:00 pm

Giteau wasn't cited.

Dodgy.

· Reply · Report

Kevin August 10, 2009 6:21 pm

i'd much rather see the actual passage of play that lead to a penalty rather than the kick itself.

· Reply · Report

jamesp August 10, 2009 7:43 pm

hmm winning a game by mainly kicking, boring?

· Reply · Report

mattn August 10, 2009 7:47 pm

i didnt thin the Gitaue incident was worthy of a yellow card, as he has his eyes on the ball throughout the chase and jump, its just badly timed on his part.

England for WC 2011 (cough)

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 10, 2009 9:31 pm

I just realised that although everyone calls Steyn a goal-kicking machine, all the penalties he kicked were from fairly straightforward positions. There were none from the touchline or anything, so you'd expect any international outhalf to get them. Just thought I'd point that out.

· Reply · Report

zacaria August 10, 2009 10:37 pm

so the only backline move of the game for the boks is steyn throwing the ball into peterson face so they have to rely on hookers to do they playmaking, another snooze fest from south africa thankyou again.

· Reply · Report

Just a Fan August 11, 2009 8:19 am

Well great win by the Bokke - weldone! Sad to see that Robbies Deans men became so cynical during the match. He is a brilliant coan, and doesnt deserve that kind of legacy.

Giteau deserved to be cited....made no intention of going for the ball....it was NOWHERE NEAR Fourie, and then lead with the elbow...

Two sets of rules - SA would never have got away with that!

Wallabies gonna be a team to reckon with in the future...good young talent coming through. The back three very difficult to get through.

Pity Habana and Petersen had butter fingerss though - hoe many times did the two of them drop passes...

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 11, 2009 9:30 pm

ZACARIA - YEAH AND THEY (BOKS) STILL WON! Can't to see this Bok side play to their true potential!!

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 11, 2009 9:31 pm

wait*

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 11, 2009 9:34 pm

These aren't the best highlights (better ones on the auzzie rugger site) shows how the boks forwards dominated. This bok side is truely scary to watch & I must say if their backs start to come to the party - I don't see any team being able to match them (though it pains me greatly to admitt this!)

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 11, 2009 9:37 pm

Just watched some the match again and to be honoust - the reason the boks kick so much is because they know that there is an 80% chance their forwards will win the ball back at the breakdown (gaining much ground in the process) Simple but oh so very,very effective. Gotta hand it to PDV - although he comes across as an ass - he knows his rugger...

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 14, 2009 9:43 am

LOL any Aussie having a go at the Saffers for promoting their current form and being proud is ignorant and or totally unaware of how arrogant they are. The funny thing is that most people I have met (non Aussie or Saffer) generally prefer Saffers. Moreover I have never met an Aussie who doesn't think they are are best in the world at everything and most have little if not no idea of what occurs outside of Aus (And they call Americans ignorant).

· Reply · Report

Anonymous August 17, 2009 9:03 am

to anonymous above, saying what you did about Australia just screams ignorance mate, hate to say it

· Reply · Report

Commenting as Guest | Register or Login

All comments are moderated and will be removed immediately if offensive.
 
Site Meter