Thursday, September 30, 2010
Ryan Kankowski suspended following stamp against the Lions
The dynamic number eight seemingly lashed out at Lions loose forward Trevor Hall while Hall hung after clearing Kankowski out of the ruck.
Up and coming referee Jason Jhafta was advised by his touch judge, resulting in the yellow card. Kankowski was later cited for stamping an opponent under law 10.4 (b) following a Saru judicial hearing that took place via conference call.
He pleaded not guilty with his defence arguing that he was in the process of falling backwards off balance, which forced him to lift the one leg to regain it, then accidentally stepping on Halls midriff.
After considering relevant facts and video evidence, the disciplinary officer recommended a suspension of two weeks, but later reduced it to just one week, ruling that Kankowskis offence was not reckless, or malicious, but was done impulsively as a reaction.
He will miss the Sharks meeting with the Leopards this weekend.
Please note that there is now a Facebook Share button below the video which makes sharing posts with your friends much neater and more effective than before. Try it out and you'll see that you can select the correct image, edit the text, and even add your own note!
Time: 01:35
Posted at 3:56 pm | 29 comments
|
|
Viewing 29 comments
Bradders September 30, 2010 3:43 pm
looks like he knew what he was doing, there was quite a bit of downward force in the stamp.
not many players who wouldn't do it though, whatever the level if being held onto like that.
not many players who wouldn't do it though, whatever the level if being held onto like that.
Jake September 30, 2010 3:44 pm
I can't stand to see rugby players with their hands up calling for a penalty... Play to the whistle. This is not a sport for whining.
Cmon September 30, 2010 4:03 pm
Totally agree with ye Jake.
How old is this ref btw, 12?
How old is this ref btw, 12?
olwakachangchang September 30, 2010 4:52 pm
I haven't watched it but will voice my generic opinions anyway:
From this clip you can see... That was nothing, rugby is turning into soccer / The referees aren't consistent / He should be banned for life / Richie McCaw is the man / PDV should be fired / South Africans are whiners / The northern hemisphere sucks / Wayne Barnes is a plonker.
Pick which ever you'd like to support / argue against.
From this clip you can see... That was nothing, rugby is turning into soccer / The referees aren't consistent / He should be banned for life / Richie McCaw is the man / PDV should be fired / South Africans are whiners / The northern hemisphere sucks / Wayne Barnes is a plonker.
Pick which ever you'd like to support / argue against.
Chris September 30, 2010 5:00 pm
You people make me laugh. Downard pressure? There wouldn't even be mark with that.
That's not a stamp, that's placing your foot on someones chest.
That's not a stamp, that's placing your foot on someones chest.
edbok September 30, 2010 5:35 pm
I wonder if he got the extra week for pleading not guilty...
I mean it was clearly a stamp, not a bad one, but it was petulant and he can't complain about the yellow.
A yellow though really should have been sufficient punishment, I guess next time just admit you messed up and move on.
I mean it was clearly a stamp, not a bad one, but it was petulant and he can't complain about the yellow.
A yellow though really should have been sufficient punishment, I guess next time just admit you messed up and move on.
Hmm September 30, 2010 6:17 pm
I thought we'd established that to get suspended your offence has to be worthy of a red?
Or is that for internationals only or what? Remember how Cooper & JDV got suspended because their spears were considered red card offences.
So confusing
Or is that for internationals only or what? Remember how Cooper & JDV got suspended because their spears were considered red card offences.
So confusing
isaac September 30, 2010 8:01 pm
Only a week, so he can't be too upset with the ruling, but still I don't think he deserved it at all. Yellow would've been enough, and I don't even really think a card was needed either, but whatever.
It seems like officials are now almost rewarding players for being little shits. The refs don't see it, so they don't penalize it, and if a player takes offense does something minor such as this, he gets suspended.
It seems like officials are now almost rewarding players for being little shits. The refs don't see it, so they don't penalize it, and if a player takes offense does something minor such as this, he gets suspended.
William September 30, 2010 8:20 pm
Some downward pressure initially, but I don't think it was a stamp, maybe just aggression. Yellow would have been sufficiant.
(u-p)rick September 30, 2010 10:38 pm
if im totally honest im not one of these 'rugby is turning gay' sort of comment leaving person...(unless it comes to raking the sh*t out of someone on the wrong side. removing that rule is gay!!)
But seriously, this is gay...
I'd be pissed to be banned for a week for that....he blatantly didnt get his money's worth with that...
from the first angle it looks bad...the second angle just looks weak...
In reply to someone commenting on players appealing to penalties, i thought the same initially, but then the guy on the floor could have thought the flag was against him for holding onto kankowski...(but i could be wrong then...)
Anyway, this was a weak stamp and the fact he got a ban for it is just sad...
p.s I wonder if he'd have got a ban if it had happened earlier in the match...where he'd have had a full 10 mins in the bin :-/
But seriously, this is gay...
I'd be pissed to be banned for a week for that....he blatantly didnt get his money's worth with that...
from the first angle it looks bad...the second angle just looks weak...
In reply to someone commenting on players appealing to penalties, i thought the same initially, but then the guy on the floor could have thought the flag was against him for holding onto kankowski...(but i could be wrong then...)
Anyway, this was a weak stamp and the fact he got a ban for it is just sad...
p.s I wonder if he'd have got a ban if it had happened earlier in the match...where he'd have had a full 10 mins in the bin :-/
Bill September 30, 2010 11:45 pm
Hoenstly, didn't look intentional to me at all.
If you losing your balance, you'll put your foot down pretty fast to regain it.
That's what it looked like to me, don't think there was anything in it really.
If you losing your balance, you'll put your foot down pretty fast to regain it.
That's what it looked like to me, don't think there was anything in it really.
facepalm October 01, 2010 12:26 am
Just as a comparison, in the Northampton-Saracens match the other day, Northampton's no.9 - Lee Dickson - catapulted himself onto a Saracens player (can't remember who), and was penalized (no card, which is good...I guess) by Dave Pearson. Even though I disagree with that kind of behavior, and wouldn't have disapproved of a yellow card, Pearson handled the situation well.
As far as I know, Dickson hasn't been cited or anything. Kankowski's act was a slap on the wrist to Hall compared to what Dickson did, and here he is getting sidelined for a week.
...dunno why.
As far as I know, Dickson hasn't been cited or anything. Kankowski's act was a slap on the wrist to Hall compared to what Dickson did, and here he is getting sidelined for a week.
...dunno why.
facepalm October 01, 2010 12:27 am
Just to clarify, by "catapulted himself onto", I mean he jumped up and came down studs a-blazin'.....he stamped him...
BrickFight October 01, 2010 3:25 am
Can RD get us a clip of this "catapult"? I'm fairly interested now.
Also, I'll assume that the sharks still came away with the win if Kankowski still got cited for that. And furthermore, I thought this was supposed to be a sport with balls. What the fuck ever happened to that? They're citing anyone and everyone for absolutely anything these days. You'd think they got paid by the citation or something.
Also, I'll assume that the sharks still came away with the win if Kankowski still got cited for that. And furthermore, I thought this was supposed to be a sport with balls. What the fuck ever happened to that? They're citing anyone and everyone for absolutely anything these days. You'd think they got paid by the citation or something.
JJamie October 01, 2010 3:39 am
Nothing in it, who cares, on with the game. Kanko is hardly a dirty player!
Andymo October 01, 2010 7:48 am
The ref calls the 2nd advantage incorrectly (for the stamp) since the stamp happened before the 1st penalty.
Anonymous October 01, 2010 9:47 am
Any chance we can chill on the gay bashing on here?
Anonymous October 01, 2010 12:32 pm
Lions rant doing to bad this yeah in the curry cup. Who the black fella at 1st 5 watch a couple games he seems like a attacking 1st 5 bit of a change for saffa traditional 1st 5 is he gunna be the goods in the future?
Anonymous October 01, 2010 1:12 pm
I kinda of agree with Bill about the incident . I think he didn't realise that the player was there .
-B
-B
cheyanqui October 01, 2010 4:45 pm
It may be a bit harsh on Kanko, but overall a great message from SA Rugby.
SA Rugby needs to crack down on foul play at the domestic level.
The reason being is that players need to get it out of their systems.
The citing commissions and referees in the international comps don't put up with the argy-bargy the Saffas like.
If you allow it in the Currie Cup, then the players don't know how to turn it off when they play Super Rugby or Test matches.
SA Rugby needs to crack down on foul play at the domestic level.
The reason being is that players need to get it out of their systems.
The citing commissions and referees in the international comps don't put up with the argy-bargy the Saffas like.
If you allow it in the Currie Cup, then the players don't know how to turn it off when they play Super Rugby or Test matches.
Chris October 01, 2010 5:12 pm
Yellow card was deserved for the stomp, though I'm not sure about the extra week.
I personally think the guy on the ground should get sited as well, because it looks like the guy standing was reacting to some work being done at knee level.
I had this exact same thing happen to me a few weeks ago.... guy at the side of a ruck had me ankle below the knee, and tried to twist and push on my knee. I looked down and his head was right by my other boot.... if it had been anything other than his head, I would have given him a lovely 8-stud tattoo.
People would flop less if the restrictions on boots were reduced.
I personally think the guy on the ground should get sited as well, because it looks like the guy standing was reacting to some work being done at knee level.
I had this exact same thing happen to me a few weeks ago.... guy at the side of a ruck had me ankle below the knee, and tried to twist and push on my knee. I looked down and his head was right by my other boot.... if it had been anything other than his head, I would have given him a lovely 8-stud tattoo.
People would flop less if the restrictions on boots were reduced.
farz October 01, 2010 8:44 pm
I hate saying it but I'm not opposed to the yellow, was a dumb thing to do. I can understand his frustration of being held though and the tackling player's left hand is in a suspicious area..I'd stamp to.
Letguysplayrugby October 02, 2010 1:31 am
Cheyanqui dude, you must be a ref.
Everytime there is a soft foul you seem to defend the lame call.
In this case the guy on the ground is not playing rugby and is interfering with a player trying to do so. This isn't a foul, a card, or a penalty.
Everytime there is a soft foul you seem to defend the lame call.
In this case the guy on the ground is not playing rugby and is interfering with a player trying to do so. This isn't a foul, a card, or a penalty.
TB October 02, 2010 1:34 am
BrickFight: you said a mouthful! Referees seem to be blowing the whistle more than ever.
I hate referees that want to put their stamp on a game and bring an agenda.
I hate referees that want to put their stamp on a game and bring an agenda.
BigBucks October 03, 2010 8:43 am
Not sure if its my bad eye sight or not, but it looked like the Lions guy held onto the Kowski's foot and he was just shaking him off - Might of been a little stamp in the process but yellow should of been it
Anonymous October 03, 2010 11:02 pm
that was a weak yellow, he didn't even do much. Dam rugby is becoming soft. So taclking will be illegal.
Anonymous October 04, 2010 12:59 pm
How old was that referee , are they sure a ball boy didn`t rob the referees jersey and chance his arm
WIN a signed copy of All Black captain Richie McCaw's autobiography
Connacht produce massive upset as they beat Toulouse in France
Pio Tuwai's incredible pass sets up Fijian try against New Zealand Sevens
South Africa pay tribute to former leader with 2013 SA Sevens win
All 16 Sevens teams pay tribute to Nelson Mandela
Seven incredible tries from the 2013 South Africa Sevens
Brian O'Driscoll's pass through the legs sets up Luke Fitzgerald try
Kieran Read awarded Player of the Year at NZ Steinlager Awards
The Springboks and Nelson Mandela - RIP Madiba
Newcastle's Richard Mayhew crunches Harlequins' Sam Smith
George North and Richard Hibbard huge hits in lead up to Israel Folau try
Courtney Lawes returns to Premiership with huge tackle on Phil Godman
Wing JP Pietersen's big tackle on Eighthman David Denton
Tevita Kuridrani receives five week suspension for dangerous tackle
Steve Thompson's incredible 80m try for England Legends + post match reaction
Justin Tipuric scores two great tries against Newport Gwent Dragons
Mathieu Bastareaud charges through lock Alexandre Flanquart
England Sevens star Matt Turner's Monkey's Tail - Movember 2013
Georgia stun Samoa in historic game in Tbilisi
Nick 'Honey Badger' Cummins interviews Wallaby players after Wales win
Friday Funnies - The Dominic Day knee slide cramp celebration
Friday Funnies - Turnstile defence from mic'd up Andy Gomarsall
Friday Funnies - Nick Easter takes a tumble over a drinks cooler
Friday Funnies - David Smith scores a try by playing all positions
Rugby HQ's Top 7 Sevens Moments of All Time
The Top 10 'Out of Africa' Moments of All Time
The Top 5 Crazy Cards of All Time - Rugby HQ
The Top Five Tackles Gone Wrong Of All Time
The Top 5 Rugby Villains of All Time - Rugby HQ
Rugby HQ's Plays of the Year for Test Rugby in 2013
Rugby HQ'S Plays of the Week - Rugby Championship penultimate weekend
Super Rugby Plays of the 2013 Season
Plays of the Week - Super Rugby Qualifiers and final round
Plays of the Week - The Lions Series Awards
Try Savers & Rib Breakers 12 - Rugby World Cup 2011 Edition
Try Savers & Rib Breakers 11
Try Savers & Rib Breakers 10
Try Savers & Rib Breakers 9
Try Savers & Rib Breakers 8 - PAIN
Commenting as Guest | Register or Login