World XV convincingly beat Japan

Josh Kronfeld & Highlanders celebrate!

Get 2 Months Free Professional Rugby S&C

The Wraparound from Rugby HQ - Week 27

Awkward interview with 'Honey Bear'

Touching Haka from Under 20's

Wallabies 31-man squad for RWC 2015

Jerry Collins' club perform Haka

Toulon play the France '98 FIFA WC squad

Wednesday, January 25, 2012

Nathan Hines hangs onto two Ulster players

Clermont Auvergne will face Saracens in the quarter finals of the Heineken Cup following their hard fought 19-15 win over Ulster on Saturday. Below is a look at a unique bit of foul play that infuriated Ulster fans.

In recent times we've featured incidents where holding onto a player results in a retaliation in the form of someone lashing out, and in some cases even, a punch and red card.

Usually it's just a jersey or arm tugging that prevents someone from getting to the next phase of play, but in the case of Nathan Hines on the weekend, he managed to take out two players at once.

Unfortunately for Clermont his indiscretion cost them a try as he held onto not only Stephen Ferris, but Pedrie Wanneburg as well. Both players did well to not take a swing at him, although shortly after Lee Byrne crossed for what would have been a try, a scuffle broke out with multiple players.

Some would have liked to have seen Hines yellow carded for such a cynical piece of gamesmanship, but referee Dave Pearson and his assistant decided that a penalty was sufficient punishment.

Many of you wanted to see the incident again, so have a look and let us know in the comments what you think of the way it was handled by the players involved and the officials.

Posted by Rugbydump at 11:05 am | View Comments (32)

Paul Williams red card for strike on Heinrich Brussow

Sean O'Brien's backhand strike on Yannick Nyanga

Paul O'Connell red card for swinging arm

Nathan Hines swinging arm on Lee Byrne

Posted in Big Hits & Dirty Play

Viewing 32 comments

Juan- Martin to the January 25, 2012 12:29 pm

Missed the part five minutes later when clermont score, with Hines clearing a path just to the righthand side of the ruck leading to a simple/ illegal try.

· Reply · Report

BarryT January 25, 2012 12:31 pm

the saddest part of that match was hines getting penalised for holding onto the 2 lads, then later in the match taking out chris henry at the side of the ruck so the sub hooker for clermont could slip in for an easy try, if hines had been carded that wouldn't have happened and possibly ulster could have the home quarter....who knows! bad sportsmanship cause clermont were PROBABLY gonna score anyway but there was no need to do it illegally, great match though

· Reply · Report

mdunlop9 January 25, 2012 12:45 pm

He's holding down Tuohy as well!

· Reply · Report

rugbydas January 25, 2012 12:53 pm

i got to say though, it looks hilarious.

· Reply · Report

patedelievre January 29, 2012 7:12 pm

absolutely hilarious!

· Reply · Report

Colombes January 25, 2012 1:14 pm

Comical but cynical action by Hines. in fact, he was hanging 3 players.
Logical decision, no try and penalty for ulster. Even this foul was blatant, many are hard to see, good to see an assistant check at it
Ps: Hines even did a block on the jaunards try

but to summarize clermont win on these 2 actions would be easy, they were far more dominant, and ulster were also cheating in many rucks.

· Reply · Report

Miro- January 25, 2012 3:05 pm

Ye - Ulster fucked up the game pretty well in those rucks :(
Damn irish style of playing rugby.

· Reply · Report

sp1nlo0p January 25, 2012 1:37 pm

refs should have picked it up way earlier AND the players which were held should have freed themselves instead of appealing to the referees

· Reply · Report

blobber January 25, 2012 2:53 pm

You ever tried freeing your leg from under a 19st unit who doesn't want you to? No, didn't think so...

Glad the assistant ref noticed something for once.

· Reply · Report

EyEBroW MoDjO January 25, 2012 3:08 pm

That was the only way to prevent Ulstermen to be offside or hands on the ball on each ruck since the ref didn't do anything for that all game long!

· Reply · Report

Ciaran January 25, 2012 5:05 pm

You'll find that he's in fact holding three players - Touhy is also underneath him.

· Reply · Report

Tristan January 25, 2012 5:52 pm

That was horrendously cynical play, three players down? A penalty may have been too lenient to warn him off doing it again, as shown five minutes later

· Reply · Report

thbts January 25, 2012 6:14 pm

And Parra, still in the middle of the fight...

· Reply · Report

Reality January 25, 2012 6:20 pm

Ahah, I like all the Clermont supporters here claiming that Ulster are the real cheats. Did you not watch the video? And did you not see your completely illegal try as well? Come on! Be realistic. Ulster weren't the better team here but they were beaten by 4 points where 7 Clermont points came from the most obviously illegal try since Mike Philips versus Ireland. Also, remember Brock James's 'knock-on' where he slapped the ball to the ground in the middle of an Ulster move, and then the ref gave a scrum instead of a penalty, and then reversed it when Muller pointed out that it was a deliberate knock-on? And you call Ulster the cheats?

· Reply · Report

i love bacon January 25, 2012 10:23 pm

That's how Clermont supporters are: fervent in their belief that their team in infallible. Watching home Top 14 matches is almost unbearable. There aren't many sides whose fans harass the ref as much as Clermont's do. Like the Philadelphia Eagles or Boston Red Sox fans of French rugby.

· Reply · Report

Vanadyel January 25, 2012 7:29 pm

Ulster have play quite foul on lots of rucks, slowing down the ball.
And I've seen a lot of bad refereeing in favor of Ulster as well.

I guess we fans have a one-way opinion on refereeing.

· Reply · Report

Carlos January 25, 2012 7:29 pm

In the last Clermont try by Ti'i Paulo how come isn't that a penaty from Hines? Ulster 7 wasn't engaging the ruck so you can't do that right?

· Reply · Report

Darth Vader January 25, 2012 7:43 pm

If that had been a defender holding on to three attacking players, there would have been a yellow card produced for definite. It would have been viewed as directly influencing whether a try would be scored or not.

Here, because it is the attacker, it is somehow viewed differently. Why no yellow card? As it transpired, a similar tactic from the same player did in fact swing the match.

· Reply · Report

McGraMaha January 25, 2012 9:14 pm

If your not cheating your not trying.

And how can Ferris, Wannenburg and Tuohy normally barrel through folk week in week out but at this point not one of them could escape the grips of a man lying down.

Was cynical by Hines but they where playing on it trying to get him carded or buy the penalty which is just as bad.

· Reply · Report

Guy January 25, 2012 9:32 pm

Don't make it bigger than it is:

a) an actually quite funny piece of foul play;
b) the try being disallowed and a penalty to the opposing team is punishment enough;
c) Ulster players did exactly what they should do: appeal to the linesman instead of taking justice in their own hands.

I had a good chuckle watching this anyhow.

· Reply · Report

Canadian content January 25, 2012 11:36 pm

i agree with darth vader but also found the whole thing quite comical. impressive feat of strength actually, those are some big units he's impeding.

· Reply · Report

Ando January 26, 2012 1:04 am

Incredible self-control from the two Ulster players not to lash out, but what disgraceful unsportsmanlike behaviour from the Clermont forward!

You know who else is good at doing this sneaky/cheaty off-the-ball stuff? The All Blacks are masters of it, particularly that man McCaw. I recall in the last Tri Nations 2011 match that a couple of ABs held down Pocock for something like 10+ seconds after a ruck, which gave them time to create an overlap and Nonu I think it was went over to score. Pocock the whole time was appealing to the touch judges but they didn't see it. Rugby doesn't need that crap...

· Reply · Report

Ref January 26, 2012 12:30 pm

In the particular piece I believe you will find it was Pocock who was holding them! He only complained to the touchie after the fact he realised it didnt work

· Reply · Report

Calon Lan January 27, 2012 1:34 am

I didn't see the match so this is the first time I've seen this.

Terrible play by Hines to be honest but I couldn't stop laughing at it. Not sure which was the funniest part, the way he held onto them both, the way the both pretended they couldn't get away while really over emphasising their movements or the "what did I do boss" look on Hines' face when he was being cautioned.

· Reply · Report

Sankeor January 27, 2012 4:34 am

3 big guys, what a skill ! haha...
No really the game was great, and Clermont played hard and better against a team which, in my opinion, used a foul play to compensate and tilt the scale towards its side (I just say, coz according to the vid one could think the opposite).
I have to say the very "liberal" style of the referee didn't help too, but Clermont really won by the sweat of their brows.

· Reply · Report

rufty January 27, 2012 12:36 pm

Must say the discipline of the Ulster lads involved was top notch. Many's a player that would lash out at such blatant cheating.

· Reply · Report

Pretzel January 28, 2012 3:06 am

I am a fan of hines but I find this awful. I was screaming blue murder when hines got done for that swipe on byrnes after being held, so I'm glad to see it swings the other way.

Seen it time and time again players being held resorting to dishing out their own punishment only for THEM to be carded, glad the ref sorted this out, although, wouldn't have blamed the ulster men for giving hines a clout!

· Reply · Report

Dourauldscot January 28, 2012 10:36 am

Funnily enough, Hines has made a lot of fans out the way he comically dealt with a load of sore Ulster fans on Twitter. Got a lot of support from people, including Ulster fans….. @wagga5. A selection below:

I tell you what @JamesWMagee07 @PJBann_8 , if there was a European Competition for whining, you wouldn't need to cheat. Would win it easy
@JamesWMagee07 Every player does what they need to do to win, including Ulster players.Wouldn't be whining if the boot was on the other foot
@bigross1970 You obviously hated every minute I played at Leinster then. Would you still be whining if I did the same for then?
@pwmckee I see that you are unhappy Paul. I am just glad that there are no foreign "journeymen" playing for Ulster.
@andyhaz88 It's all part of the game Andrew. Getting stick from the other fans is a compliment in a funny way
@chazz_10 Thanks Charlie but I think that we handled your ulster men sufficiently enough to win the game.?
@JackChapman9 and of course the same abuse would be given from the ulster collective if an ulsterman had done the same thing. #notsosure
It's OK @AJMaitly. Sometimes if you don't have a great understanding of rugby, it's easy to miss the less obvious blocking.
@bacon_ben Thank you Ben for your kind words. I find the "clever" use of swear words with xenophobic references somewhat amusing.

…… Legend

· Reply · Report

Pretzel January 28, 2012 1:02 pm

I wrote my last comment in a hurry.

I do find it funny, because lets face it this is outrageous, he stops 3 guys... I know he did what he needed to do, or felt he needed to do, and for some part I understand it (everyone does it). What really grinds me though is when players retaliate and get punished. See Danny Grewcock with regards to his stamp on ferris arm...where ferris holds on to grewocks arm and leg (whilst lying on the floor) and grewcock stamps his arm, Ferris "shouts in pain" towards the referee... result: Grewcock red!

Now, its in the red zone of the field (RIGHT IN FRONT OF THE TRY LINE!) and grewcock the defending player is being held! EXACTLY the same happens here, (with more players lol) if it had been missed and someone went through the edge to score because ferris was being held he'd have been livid, so honestly I reckon the only reason ferris didn't swipe out was because it was Hines (a rather large unit!)

So I hope that more often than not these things get blown up quickly, either that or let a player take a swipe!

· Reply · Report

Logo December 16, 2013 4:42 pm

Ulster's #8 should have just stamped on Nathan Hines knee/shin. He might have let go then. These "professional" fouls need eradicating from the sport ASAP. They're worse than the thuggery it should meet IMO.

· Reply · Report

Guest December 16, 2013 6:19 pm

I would've rucked the c*%ts spine with my free leg till he let go!! No place for this shit on the pitch blatant cheating piss off an play football you prick Hines

· Reply · Report

Commenting as Guest | Register or Login

All comments are moderated and will be removed immediately if offensive.