Viewing comments for Facepalm« back to profile

Outcry as Florian Fritz returns to play after severe knock to head

It seems clear to me that three things need to happen here.

1) Appoint an independent doctor to carry out impartial concussion tests. This way there will be no bias to keep a player on the pitch. The only concern will be of individual player welfare.

2) Scrap the 10 minute rule. The medical staff were so rushed for time and, as you said, seemed too preoccupied with the blood to focus on the more pressing issue. The assessment has to stringently cover all aspects of the player's situation. Pressurising whoever's in charge with an arbitrary time constraint is madness.

3) Sack whoever was responsible for allowing Fritz back onto the pitch - be it the manager or the medics.

7 Months, 1 Week ago

Tom Court shown straight red card for tip tackle on Devin Toner

Those are my thoughts exactly. Each player has lifted a leg not realising the other has also done likewise. By the time they try to react, Toner's 6ft11 frame has been flipped upside down, which is quite a feat. Picking which player to punish is like playing a game of eenie meenie miny moe (hopefully not Jeremy Clarkson's version).

Regardless, I really don't like Muller's comments. He got arsey with the ref over the Payne incident as well. He knows his voice is getting picked up on the refs mic and shouldn't be pulling that shit. By turning the ref against you it's also the worst thing you can do for your team.

7 Months, 2 Weeks ago

The new European Rugby Champions Cup explained

For Rabo clubs already strapped for cash surely the prospect of more European games can only be good.

I remember a few years ago when the recession was at its worst they were considering adding some extra games to the Aviva season purely for this reason.

7 Months, 3 Weeks ago

The new European Rugby Champions Cup explained

I wouldn't take anything Austin Healy says seriously. This is clearly favourable to English and French teams and I can't believe the Irish actually agreed to this.

Personally I think there should be more spots given to playoffs. Make it a true *meritocracy and let the borderline teams battle it out.

7 Months, 3 Weeks ago

Heineken Cup 2014 Quarter Final Highlights

Out of interest, what would your decision have been were you the referee?

8 Months, 1 Week ago

Heineken Cup 2014 Quarter Final Highlights

Why does the fact that his eyes were on the ball make the contact less dangerous? Payne made no attempt to compete. The actions of his body are clearly more important than the direction of his eyes. Goode came down with a sickening thud. Correct decision to give a red.

What was incredible was the heart shown by Ulster. I honestly don't believe any other team in the tournament could've been that competitive given the circumstances. Gotta feel for Paddy Jackson. I so wanted Ulster to win.

8 Months, 1 Week ago

Carlin Isles dropped ball blooper ruins great fifteens debut try

Usually when someone loses control of the ball over the line it's a knock on so any grounding thereafter doesn't count. But in a weird situation like this the ball goes backwards when he drops it. So the game's still live and he's free to ground the ball, no?

8 Months, 2 Weeks ago

Logovi'i Mulipola prop try included in Premiership Try of the Week nominations

Jamie Noon England's worst ever player?! I think not.

8 Months, 3 Weeks ago

Ireland and O'Driscoll celebrate 2014 Six Nations victory in Paris

They really need to amend the law allowing you to place the ball against the post to score a try. It becomes an virtually indefensible fringe to a ruck when the attacking team is that close. Obviously this means there's a small section of the pitch the attacking team can't score but surely that's a lesser problem than the one currently?

9 Months, 1 Day ago

England notch up 50 in Rome but Championship fate out of their hands

Wade's defence is shaky. Kuridrani swatted him like a fly on the lions tour. That said Kuridrani is an animal of a player. Joel Tomkins, for all his faults, is a pretty solid defensive unit so if he can't tackle him then Wade's missed tackle is made slightly more forgivable. Slightly.

I imagine in New Zealand Lancaster will be looking at Foden, Yarde and Nowell competing for a starting place.

9 Months, 3 Days ago

 
Site Meter