Viewing comments for Frenchie« back to profile

Ireland win 2014 Six Nations after late France forward pass

@ Oliver
These young players have been drafted but I still think it’s too shy: besides Plisson and Fickou the others have mostly sat on the bench and played very limited time.

Lauret is a good example although not exactly new. He has had a few selections already, is a physical guy and has potential, yet how much has he played for this year’s 6N? I’d be curious.
Then why selecting Vahaamahina (plays as lock in club) as flanker instead of Lauret who plays flanker in his club?
The next WC is coming fast, I think only 12 international games until the WC (?) There’s no time to have talented players polish the bench; they need some time on the pitch now.

I'd like to see what a foreign coach (he has to be from Southern Hemisphere) would do? Surely he would bring more professionalism, a more clinical way of playing, more
game plan.

1 Month, 23 Hours ago

Ireland win 2014 Six Nations after late France forward pass

I scorched names...sorry. Farrell, Burrell, Nowel...

1 Month, 1 Day ago

Ireland win 2014 Six Nations after late France forward pass

@ mise:

all this seems a bit cliché, the smoking, chatting...but i do see a cultural clash there in the sense that probably the French enjoy some relaxing time, separate work and after work.

On the coaching side: the french team is missing a good kicker when Parra is out. I guess not having much video analysis around kicking is the reason why ROG has been hired...surely the French clubs should have that.
Since Saint André is on the job we do not have a defense coach and that is quite incredible...I don't get that.

On a more general note I do think that the French are still lagging behind in terms of coaching. Besides Guy Noves & Galthié I don't see who could get the job. Noves has turned down the job, Galthié hasn't been chosen.

@ Vladimir
I think Vern Cotter would have been perfect for the job: he's been there for a long time, has had good results, built a fabulous team.

The French Federation is for me an archaic organisation, attached to traditions. It's an Institution in the bad sense. French rugby has tons of talent (the U20 just won the Grand slam) but the transition to top competition is slow and to the National team even slower; example taken with Fickou. French rugby needs a younger/clever management team turned towards a modern rugby.

If Clubs & Federation work together, talents are recognised early and involved at the highest level things will get better.

The French need to be better one 1 to 1, individual technic: 2 forward passes against Ireland...

In NZ being young is not a problem if you're talented and have a potential. if so you get the chance. In France in the same situation you need to sit on the bench and play the last 10 min for xx games. The FFR love its soldiers, old fames and the guys are playing until they retire. In NZ you see new talents coming all the time.

Same in England with the likes of Owens, Launchburry, Burrell...and these play already at a very good level; you don't need to teach them how to pass.


1 Month, 1 Day ago

Ireland win 2014 Six Nations after late France forward pass

Not that it matters much anymore, especially for the French haters, but I honestly think that there was no knock on. It seems to me that Swarziesky always kept contact with the ball when grounding.
I’d admit it was close but nowadays you see tons of tries granted by the refs with a minimal contact on the ball.

Healey should have been carded for the headbutt and surely would have France score points (if not a try). In 2nd half the scrum was all France…surprisingly.

A question for the experts:
On the scrum topic I read Domingo saying that for him being small it is very difficult to scrummage with the new rules. He continues that typically in France the props start the scrum “sitting” low then push the scrum ”up” and stabilize their position.
The new rules state that you should enter on a flat position (or so) but for small props this is for him very difficult.

Following Walsh warning at half time Domingo has been replaced by Debaty who is a tall prop and that worked pretty nicely for the French…is it the end of small props?

Well done Ireland

1 Month, 1 Day ago

France break Scottish hearts with late winning penalty at Murrayfield

@ Phil Mc avity:

I don't understand what you say, why you take the arrogance angle into your discussion.
You talk like you were mad, I can't take you seriously.
The French play bad, they don't show much envy etc…but that does not make them arrogant. I believe they need a real captain on the pitch, Dusautoir is badly missed.
It is simply very messy, the coaches are poor and there's no good game plan.

Still this team wins game…so there must be something deep in them. THINGS NEED TO CHANGE, AND QUICK.

1 Month, 1 Week ago

France break Scottish hearts with late winning penalty at Murrayfield

@ Phil mc avity :
you should stop calling the French players "arrogant" mate. What makes them arrogant? To be playing bad and still win?
I agree when you say that they play for themselves; I believe that the message given by St Andre/Lagisquet is not being listened, understood by the players; hence the horrible mess that they show on the pitch.
The French press does not understand why St Andre does, 90% of the fans hate that guy.
He has the poorest results a French coach has ever had in his first 3 years in charge!

We've been missing (injuries & non selected) loads of players and it does not help our game. True there's no captain anymore. To name a few: Dusautoir, Nyanga, Parra, Picamoles, Fofana, Trinh Duc, Swarziesky, Kayser, Fickou. But the subs are not playing at the level they should be playing and that's another worry for me. Also the props said they don't understand how to apply the new rules, they don'tt know exactly what's expected from them…this to say that there's a lot of bad coaching.

Scotland played better but not well enough…France stole the game. Don't forget that one try should have been disallowed for Scotland. How did they loose that game??


1 Month, 1 Week ago

Wales bounce back with strong win over France in Cardiff

@ DrG :
I saw the head butt and I agree with you. But if you talk about "principle" and think that a coach should punish his player for showing disrespect by clapping at the ref, it is for me moronic for the same coach to welcome bak a player who tried to head butt his opponent.

Nowhere has Picamoles shown a aggressive behaviour towards Rolland and we are far from what you described on the football pitch. For me the coach should have warned Picamoles in private like he did with Vahamaina; put him on the bench.

Saint Andre is sending the wrong message; again. He's dumb; don't know if you speak French but hearing him speak is painful.

And yes...if Picamoles was a bad player I wouldn't mind so much but we need him!

1 Month, 2 Weeks ago

Scotland snatch victory from Italy with late drop goal in Rome

Exciting game coming up at Murrayfield…who would have thought?? Should be a cracker.

1 Month, 2 Weeks ago

Wales bounce back with strong win over France in Cardiff

@ Stroudos: Saint Andre is a fool and very contradictory. He punishes Picamoles, undoubtedly one of the best in the world for his gesture but calls out Parra after he head butted a player…SERIOUSLY?

You should be shocked seeing Farrell play after what he did against Scotland and Ireland. I don't think Picamoles gesture was that nasty. DO YOU KNOW WHY HE GOT CARDED? I don't.

1 Month, 2 Weeks ago

Wales bounce back with strong win over France in Cardiff

A non game by the French. They showed their real level i'm afraid. I thought the ref was very harsh towards the French. The prop Mas told the press that the Welsh pushed way too early, before the scrum was stable.
I thought the Welsh were just better, but surely not incredible. They pushed the French, played too quick and never let the French space.
Our scrum/fly halves were very ba, there was no link between the forwards and the backs (Picamoles got isolated), and Bastareau should be on the bench.

We need to see Parra, Trinh Duc, Fickou urgently Mr Saint André!

There's a lot of grief towards Papé in the press being too mouthy.

For me that try from Warburton is very dodgy; not sure about how to read the rule there but I think that it should be seems as a double movement: ball is grounded short the man is stopped then the ball is rolled away; that's not done in the same movement. Anyway...

1 Month, 3 Weeks ago

 
Site Meter