Viewing comments for alasdairduncan3« back to profile

Michael Hooper makes unwanted history with record breaking yellow card

This video doesn't show much. There were 2 nails collapsed, 2 pens at the breakdown, and a wonderful display of trying to ignore his way out of the card.

Still a fantastic player but he deserved this yellow.

4 Weeks, 2 Hours ago

Scotland upset Australia in tight encounter in Sydney

Fantastic win, great to see Finn getting his Lions call up too, far more deserving than Biggar and most of Gatlands Wales mates. Hamish Watson in great form too.

5 Months, 4 Weeks ago

Werner Kok explodes as Sevuloni Mocenacagi gets sent off in Las Vegas 7s final

I agree,
Kok shouldn't have come on so strong, but Mocenacagi definitely should have shown more care with Kok.

9 Months, 1 Week ago

Werner Kok explodes as Sevuloni Mocenacagi gets sent off in Las Vegas 7s final

Surely statistics versus similar danger in a tackle situation are irrelevant, as both are policed in the same way.

Definitely potential for serious and life changing neck or back injury in collisions such as this. Are you suggesting we wait until someone is paralysed from the neck down before we continue with the current crackdown on this sort of dangerous play?

9 Months, 1 Week ago

Edinburgh's Burleigh sent off amid Papé playacting

I feel like I'm watching a slightly different clip to the commentators/ref/some of you.

1. Pape does have a pretty clear little slap himself as he's about to back away, which is obviously the provocation.
2. Burleigh does take a decent fast uppercut shot at Pape, so I'm not surprised he saw the red.
3. Burleigh's hand doesn't look open to me. Looks like he strikes with his knuckles with his hand about 'half open'.
4. Yeh, Pape didn't need to go down, but if I just got hit in the face like that I'd definitely have a little lie down too.

I do think that if players do any diving they should be strung up by the goolies.

1 Year, 5 Days ago

George North free to play after sickening landing worries fans

These situations have got to be extremely tough for the players.
They have so little time to react, and going with your instinct to tackle even slightly will get them cited. Very difficult to react.

1 Year, 1 Week ago

Tevita Kuridrani scores sensational try to seal Aussie win in France

Simple translation:

If it touches the post it's ok.

If it's touching the post when it touches the ground, it's out.

Simple way to understand it is to pretend the flag doesn't exist.

No try.

1 Year, 3 Weeks ago

Joe Launchbury in trouble for kick to Fijian head at breakdown

No idea what's going on there. Isn't there another angle?

1 Year, 3 Weeks ago

Matt Toomua escapes red card decision after dumping Finn Russell

The tackle was just as dangerous as any where the player lands on his head, it just happens that Russell managed to break his fall with his elbow.

My common sense interpretation of the rules would make that a red, what do you think?

1 Year, 2 Months ago

Taqele Naiyaravoro banned for taking out Beauden Barrett in the air

I don't think I've seen a clearer or more obvious reckless intent.

1 Year, 5 Months ago