Viewing comments for browner« back to profile

James Horwill cleared after alleged stamp on Alun-Wyn Jones in first Test

If this face stamp isn't a minimum Top End ban, then the Disciplinary Panel should all resign. Face stamping = no place in rugby - EVER

JH best defense would be to admit trying to stamp on AWJ but claim that he lost his balance as he crossed his legs & missed the shoulder he was aiming for !!!

Even that should get laughed out of the hearing !

IRB are you listening .......? Face stamping should have it's own 'sanctions' category 10.4[b] doesn't fit this action.

set up 10.4.b [1] Stamping above the shoulder
Low 52+ weeks
Mid 104+ weeks
Top 156+
with Life Bans for if the injured player is severely injured.



1 Year, 4 Months ago

James Horwill cleared after alleged stamp on Alun-Wyn Jones in first Test

S&S, you've been drowning your sorrows too much- clearly still misty eyed.

Yes GN pushed IF, but there are 100's of pushing incidents in a match ...... JH's assault was 3 mins into the match off the ball deliberate premeditated & cowardly. You've embarrassed yourself by even linking the incidents - shame on you.





1 Year, 4 Months ago

The British and Irish Lions win the first Test as Kurtley Beale misses late penalties

We need a vid to look at RD ....got one?

1 Year, 4 Months ago

The British and Irish Lions win the first Test as Kurtley Beale misses late penalties

Fitzpatrick & the Hit inventors started this problem ....... IRB have spent £0.5m on a new sequence that wont stop diddly shit. Oh & next season straight feeds are going to come back in, yeah right......like the lawbook ever changed on this subject

1 Year, 4 Months ago

The British and Irish Lions win the first Test as Kurtley Beale misses late penalties

dream on

1 Year, 4 Months ago

The British and Irish Lions win the first Test as Kurtley Beale misses late penalties

Sadly, Super 14 play under the same laws...... it's the Interpretations that are different.
Surely the IRB can insist on standard interpretations, they appoint referees ..... start demoting all those who won't apply standard interpretations, all this SH NH divide is poor for the game.

If the SH want to play RL then bugger off & do it. As a Union xplayer & fan I want to see contests all over the pitch..lineout, ruck, maul, tackle, jackal, scrum feeds, hooking, kick off catches etc

It's supposed to be an international sport.

Phillips has always kept guards occupied with his taxiing, but it slows down ball to receivers , when he can't get through it looks terrible, but when it works he's a handful. everyone can see Youngs service is quicker, but if he doesnt interest the defenders they just smother the 1st/2nd receivers ..... take your pick. Croft did lots of tackling, still worth his place IMO

can't wait for next sat .......

1 Year, 4 Months ago

USA Eagle Samu Manoa's huge hit on Peter O'Mahony

Penalty to USA. Both irish 3 & 5 are forced to come in from the side because of the distance O'M travels ..... poor ref decision on that occasion, Samu's efforts unrewarded

1 Year, 5 Months ago

Lions Tour infographic featuring the Welsh contingent vs Australia

zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

1 Year, 5 Months ago

Samoa outmuscle Scotland in opening game of Quad Series in Durban

The IRB 3 yr residency rule stinks ....... If you have dual nationality qualification then select your Nation at 16 & stick with it......

Alesana Tuilagi is proof that modern players CAN reside in one country but travel to play for a country 000's of miles away without switching to play for another Nation, for that he always gets my respect - legend.

1 Year, 5 Months ago

Canada beat 14-man Tonga in eventful Pacific Nations Cup clash

That's outrageous........ admitting you're scottish without provocation !

1 Year, 5 Months ago

 
Site Meter