Viewing comments for joeythelemur« back to profile

The Springboks claim convincing win over the Wallabies in Cape Town

Agreed that the bonus point doesn't always make sense, but "thems the rules", as they say. You could just as easily say that point differential isn't the way to determine a champion either, since playing conditions certainly affect the ability to put lots of points up (see NZ vs Arg in Hamilton compared to SA's 60 point win). In the case of a tie, I'd rather see head-to-head tries scored, or head-to-head point differential. At least then you know that it's a decider based on equal opportunity to score (meaning SA would need to beat NZ by more than 14). Just not as easy to show in a newspaper box score week to week.

I don't know that the 4-try bonus point favors a running style; I'd say SA's style is high-pressure, and that often utilizes a kicking strategy. Meyer has them running as much as ever; they put up 70+ against Argentina, put up 38 in the Wallabies backyard. They can score tries, but had bad luck in Auckland and couldn't properly seal the bonus point deal this weekend at home.

1 Year, 3 Weeks ago

The Springboks claim convincing win over the Wallabies in Cape Town

DirecTV Rugby channel (490) sometimes has them, but it seems inconsistent. I didn't see them listed this week, only ITM games, plus it's $15/mo as it's part of the sports package. Setanta used to show them, but I don't think they have in the last couple years. Might be worth checking their schedule, and that's a pay option too. Best bet is probably a live-stream online, something like livesport.tv.

1 Year, 3 Weeks ago

The Springboks claim convincing win over the Wallabies in Cape Town

After reading a bit more commentary, I agree with you that it probably was more a coaching decision to kick away possession. I haven't seen much of White but tons of Genia, so I couldn't see the rationale. Didn't seem like White and Cooper clicked when they did pass, but I suppose it's a small sample size!

Question is why McKenzie would choose to gameplan it that way when SA are definitely looking dangerous with ball in hand. Keep possession and make them earn it!

1 Year, 3 Weeks ago

The Springboks claim convincing win over the Wallabies in Cape Town

The ref will always be a discussion point out of a game with 4 yellows. Hooper's card is certainly worthy of discussion, but you don't see anyone bagging the ref generally for this game (no one is complaining about van der Merwe's card). Of course, it wasn't that close, so no one can blame the ref for blowing it for one team or the other. It doesn't feel that this year has been any better or worse than other years, though I guess it always depends on your perspective and who you support.

Not sure about the pitch. I did watch the full replay, seem to recall there was rain prior to the match (or I'm getting confused with the NZ/Arg match, as that pitch was slick as well).

1 Year, 3 Weeks ago

The Springboks claim convincing win over the Wallabies in Cape Town

Shouldn't have been allowed because Lambie rolled the ball directly at the ref? Agreed that he wasn't disrespectful, but he knew 100% what he was doing, trying to kill the opportunity to take it quick.

I'd love to be in the room for referee rating when they go through stuff like this; would they say they got it right?

1 Year, 3 Weeks ago

The Springboks claim convincing win over the Wallabies in Cape Town

I thought Australia defended exceptionally well considering the amount of pressure. A couple lapses but really could have given up much more. Sounds like the Boks felt the same way based on their frustration at not getting the bonus point.

Cooper has a reputation for not liking to tackle, but I thought he was in the thick of things, including a big stop inside his 22. Not sure if he was truly in the wilderness form-wise during the Dean's tenure, but it seems to me he's the Wallabies best option at 10 right now. Glad to see he's back.

Why doesn't Genia start? Is he coming back from injury? He was miles better than Nick White, a totally different approach after he came on. All White seemed to do was kick away possession.

1 Year, 3 Weeks ago

The Springboks claim convincing win over the Wallabies in Cape Town

Hooper pleaded a bit before his card came out, I think he was not sure what had even happened. And Lambie, kinda funny watching Owens just ignore him!

1 Year, 3 Weeks ago

The Springboks claim convincing win over the Wallabies in Cape Town

However you look at the initial infraction, Alberts was very lucky to not be penalized for the body slam after the whistle. Slamming Hooper on his shoulder/head looked at least as dangerous than how Etzebeth landed. I don't think the ref even had a word with him.

1 Year, 3 Weeks ago

The Springboks claim convincing win over the Wallabies in Cape Town

Agreed. Does anyone think that Hooper could have caused Etzebeth to flip like that on his own? No lifting, no intent. It was entirely on Etzebeth that he came down out of control.

1 Year, 3 Weeks ago

Through the Eyes of an All Black - Rugby Championship catch up with Nick Evans

Nick is solid, but I think both him and the ABs are happy where they're at. The ABs have solid depth at 10, not sure he would give them anything that they don't already have with Cruden and Barrett.

Nick was unfortunate to be understudy to Dan Carter when Carter was a world-beater and not as injury prone as he has been lately. Certainly understand him taking other opportunities and he's made the most of it.

1 Year, 3 Weeks ago

 
Site Meter