Viewing comments for mise« back to profile

Chris Hala'ufia huge hit then red card for shoving player's head into the dirt

sorry RD but I think you are giving him a serious benefit of the doubt there ...that comment what could probably be described as disgust at Pearce reacting like he did to the hit"," lays too much blame on the part of the player who was tackled, and who presented the ball! Had he not presented the ball ,maybe, but I can't see how anything could be construed as playacting? Especially when the time between tackle, ball placement and headslam was so short (even in slo mo).

11 Months, 3 Weeks ago

David Pocock's Turnover Masterclass against the Blues

Great to see him back (not great for Wales or England thou!)

and re breakdown: he's playing both the ref and the opposition - I'm sure he would have marginally adjusted his timing if the ref pinged him once...but as the ref didn't he carried on. Simples.

1 Year, 2 Weeks ago

The Fearless Warrior of Irish mythology, Paul O'Connell

seems to be better at some things than he was in the past (eg handling, passing)

V physically fit also

1 Year, 3 Weeks ago

Courtney Lawes lays into another unsuspecting flyhalf, this time Jules Plisson

re facebook and 'haters': facebook was killing the comment section here for about 2 years. People just commented over there instead.
This was
A) useless for RD and revenue
B) lowered the tone for those of us who wanted to interact on RD, as RD Facebook isn't knowledgeable or respectful (that's a facebook thing, not an RD on Facebook thing specifically!)

However if some of those facebook ppl are starting to come over here and interact, that's fine. Probably only the more committed will, we need more traffic anyway, and it'll be up to us old timers to keep things relatively respectful. Innit.

1 Year, 1 Month ago

Midweek Madness - Nigel Owens puts Chris Robshaw in his place

oh that's good. Full first name as an expression of authority. :-)

1 Year, 1 Month ago

Courtney Lawes lays into another unsuspecting flyhalf, this time Jules Plisson

core issue it seems is actually the placement of the player onto the ground, not the tackle. Tackle looks worse in slo mo, but is touch and go.
Placement is more an issue as players have a duty to place the player properly after a tackle. I know that sounds weird, but that's part of what is, technically, supposed to happen. So even if Lawes didn't deliberately tip him, the momentum of the tackle caused a tip. So, I reckon lawes had a duty to try to prevent the head from going down first. What seems to have happened is that lawes didn't do that, and may have done the opposite. He may have actually driven it a bit. Look at where the head and feet are at the very end.
Owens seems to have seen the tackle and timing and called it as fine - that's fine - but did he watch it through to the end? Possibly not - he had a game to watch!
Lawes may end up getting a ban from the citing comm for that bit at the end.

1 Year, 1 Month ago

France ease to comfortable victory over Italy at wet Stadio Olimpico

u were lucky FelipeG. It was awful. I remember seeing 19 handling errors for one team, 17 for the other popping up on the screen at one stage....that doesn't include really crap kicks obviously (eg out on the fulls).

Appalling match, sucked the life out of me as I endured it. Probably fell asleep straight afterwards...

France could be so good, but aren't (allowed be)....

Such a pity.

1 Year, 1 Month ago

The Wraparound from Rugby HQ - Week 1

he needs to be standing up - makes a big difference (eg many of the US shock jock radio presenters stand in the studio, they don't sit!)

1 Year, 2 Months ago

Sean O'Brien's monster ruck cleanout against France

thou on (yet another) look SOB is certainly resting there at the end for a while...

1 Year, 2 Months ago

Sean O'Brien's monster ruck cleanout against France

Desperate Dan stuff, that!

Sneeky headlock at the end, but great to see that SOB back.... :-)

I've heard the same sort of farmer strength talked about re the Welsh and coalminers

....its tuff down pit an all...

(I'm in Ireland)

1 Year, 2 Months ago