ADVERTISEMENT
RugbyDump
REGISTER
LOGIN
ADVERTISEMENT
RugbyDump
Saturday Dec 12, 2015

Comparing the Jared Payne and Michael Rhodes cards for similar incidents

Two very similar incidents occurred during the Europeans Champions Cup over the last two seasons between Saracens and Ulster, but both had different outcomes. After a number of requests to look at both, here’s a quick comparison.

Ulster’s Jared Payne received a red card for a nasty collision with Alex Goode when the Sarries fullback was collecting a high ball in last season’s encounter.

Both Payne and captain Johann Muller argued that the New Zealand-born back’s eyes were on the ball the whole time, but referee Jerome Garces was unmoved.

Payne received a further two week ban, and was just the latest in a long line of decisions by World Rugby when they were cracking down on challenging in the air, including this by Stuart Hogg on Dan Biggar.

During Ulster’s 27-9 loss to Saracens in November, Andrew Trimble was the recipient of a tackle in the air by Michael Rhodes. While it doesn’t look as bad as the Payne/Goode incident, Trimble’s back still smashes into the ground and commentator Austin Healey immediately calls for a red card.

What makes it look worse is the fact that Trimble keeps his leg airborne and his momentum coming down means that he collides quickly with Rhodes.

Referee Romain Poite and the TMO both agree that the tackle was worthy of a yellow card and for once, the slow-motion replay works in favour of the tackler as the challenge doesn’t look too bad.

Do you agree with the outcomes of both tackles?

You can view both incidents below, Payne first then the more recent Rhodes challenge

ADVERTISEMENT

Related Articles

  • 10 WEEKS AGO

    Retallick cheap shot on Michael Hooper missed...

  • 10 WEEKS AGO

    Outspoken de Villiers gives his unique verdict...

  • 10 WEEKS AGO

    This collection of brutal bump offs will...



ADVERTISEMENT

Great Tries

  • 6 DAYS AGO

    Analysis of Dombrandt performance shows unseen work of potential England number eight

  • 6 DAYS AGO

    Six minutes of Nick Tompkins highlights will leave fans questioning his lack of Test caps

  • 2 WEEKS AGO

    These Adam Radwan highlights reels demonstrate why fans are so excited by young speedster

  • 3 WEEKS AGO

    Kurtley Beale at the heart of stunning Barbarian-esque tries from Racing 92

  • 4 WEEKS AGO

    The very best 'trick shots' in rugby show exactly why we love this game

View All

Big Hits & Dirty Play

  • 3 DAYS AGO

    High tackle Yellow card should have been Red, results in suspension for Gabriel Oghre

  • 5 DAYS AGO

    WATCH: The worst cases of tripping in modern professional rugby

  • 5 DAYS AGO

    Eye-gouge sanction avoided by Chile, eliminate Canada from RWC contention

  • 1 WEEK AGO

    Biting gets Stormers lock Adre Smith a hefty ban

  • 1 WEEK AGO

    Stormers lock might get away with biting due to lack of clear footage

View All

See It To Believe It

  • 13 HOURS AGO

    Re-live Danny Care’s crazy brain fade which sent Martin Johnson into a rage

  • 6 DAYS AGO

    Analysis of Dombrandt performance shows unseen work of potential England number eight

  • 6 DAYS AGO

    Six minutes of Nick Tompkins highlights will leave fans questioning his lack of Test caps

  • 1 WEEK AGO

    WATCH: Hat-trick of drop goals exposes potential weakness in new law change

  • 1 WEEK AGO

    Habana's honest opinion on speed comparisons with him and Kolbe

View All

Funnies

  • 2 WEEKS AGO

    WATCH: Erasmus celebrates Boks win over All Blacks in his UNDERWEAR

  • 2 WEEKS AGO

    Twenty years on since hilarious All Blacks howler almost gave Argentina famous test win

  • 2 WEEKS AGO

    WATCH: Five minutes of Mike Phillips scrum half 'sh*thousery' is comedy gold....mostly

  • 3 WEEKS AGO

    Five minutes of Faf de Klerk on-pitch shenanigans is pure gold to watch

  • 4 WEEKS AGO

    WATCH: Montoya calls All Blacks star a pu**y in hilarious head loss moment

View All

Amateur

  • 50 WEEKS AGO

    Viral video of Scottish club brawl goes down a storm with rugby community

  • 87 WEEKS AGO

    RUGBYDUMP BLITZ: This Best of the Week round up is sure to entertain you

  • 87 WEEKS AGO

    RD BLITZ - Disaster, just when it looked so promising...

  • 87 WEEKS AGO

    That glorious moment that will live on forever, like it or not

  • 87 WEEKS AGO

    RD Blitz - PROP'S Lionel Messi wizardy creates incredible try

View All

Player Features

  • 13 HOURS AGO

    New Tongan Thor montage is five minutes of mesmerising hits and skills

  • 12 WEEKS AGO

    A deeper look at Jason Robinson's incredible path to the top

  • 34 WEEKS AGO

    WATCH: Bumping off tacklers and taking high balls, Rob Kearney had an impressive Super Rugby debut

  • 39 WEEKS AGO

    Brian Moore on money in modern rugby and how it should never be compared to 'outlier' football

  • 40 WEEKS AGO

    Tuisova's wrecking ball montage will make you grateful you never made it as a pro

View All