Do Not Sell My Personal Information
ADVERTISEMENT
RugbyDump RugbyDump
Saturday Dec 12, 2015

Comparing the Jared Payne and Michael Rhodes cards for similar incidents

Comparing the Jared Payne and Michael Rhodes cards for similar incidents

Two very similar incidents occurred during the Europeans Champions Cup over the last two seasons between Saracens and Ulster, but both had different outcomes. After a number of requests to look at both, here’s a quick comparison.

Ulster’s Jared Payne received a red card for a nasty collision with Alex Goode when the Sarries fullback was collecting a high ball in last season’s encounter.

Both Payne and captain Johann Muller argued that the New Zealand-born back’s eyes were on the ball the whole time, but referee Jerome Garces was unmoved.

Payne received a further two week ban, and was just the latest in a long line of decisions by World Rugby when they were cracking down on challenging in the air, including this by Stuart Hogg on Dan Biggar.

During Ulster’s 27-9 loss to Saracens in November, Andrew Trimble was the recipient of a tackle in the air by Michael Rhodes. While it doesn’t look as bad as the Payne/Goode incident, Trimble’s back still smashes into the ground and commentator Austin Healey immediately calls for a red card.

What makes it look worse is the fact that Trimble keeps his leg airborne and his momentum coming down means that he collides quickly with Rhodes.

Referee Romain Poite and the TMO both agree that the tackle was worthy of a yellow card and for once, the slow-motion replay works in favour of the tackler as the challenge doesn’t look too bad.

Do you agree with the outcomes of both tackles?

You can view both incidents below, Payne first then the more recent Rhodes challenge

ADVERTISEMENT

Related Articles

  • 18 WEEKS AGO

    Suspensions handed down after testicle grabbing...

  • 19 WEEKS AGO

    The 'double ruffle' splits opinion with fans...

  • 19 WEEKS AGO

    WATCH: The nastiest and most brutal moments...



ADVERTISEMENT

Great Tries

  • 4 DAYS AGO

    Aaron Smith left red faced as speedy opposite number steals a bullet behind the line

  • 4 DAYS AGO

    WATCH: Every Louis Rees-Zammit try in the Premiership so far

  • 4 DAYS AGO

    Toulouse run the length to score awesome late try in Top 14 classic

  • 5 DAYS AGO

    Wallabies legend Ashley-Cooper shows class in MLR with cheeky shoulder pass

  • 5 DAYS AGO

    WATCH: Hogg collects his own 60-metre spiral kick to score amazing solo try

View All

Big Hits & Dirty Play

  • 22 HOURS AGO

    Matu'u bemused by his ban after footage shows latest unpunished Owen Farrell shot

  • 2 DAYS AGO

    Du Preez explains thought process after dominating prop in tip tackle that went wrong

  • 4 DAYS AGO

    Prop suspended for 3 weeks after flying shoulder makes contact square in the face

  • 1 WEEK AGO

    WATCH: Aaron Smith's captain's referral turned down after swinging arm collision

  • 2 WEEKS AGO

    WATCH: 19-year-old is barely a speed bump for fearsome Fijian number eight

View All

See It To Believe It

  • 4 DAYS AGO

    WATCH: JP Doyle puts MLR players in their place with authoritative return to refereeing

  • 1 WEEK AGO

    The most iconic pieces of rugby commentary in brilliant 7-minute montage

  • 1 WEEK AGO

    'It's part of our culture' says Haka performing South African university team

  • 1 WEEK AGO

    Petrus du Plessis video of son's dominant scrum shows signs of potential future star

  • 1 WEEK AGO

    Over $450 million loss for South Africa's economy if the Lions tour happens without fans

View All

Funnies

  • 4 DAYS AGO

    WATCH: JP Doyle puts MLR players in their place with authoritative return to refereeing

  • 5 DAYS AGO

    WATCH: Comedy gold as close range 'falcon' gifts Brumbies try in Super Rugby AU match

  • 1 WEEK AGO

    Lions coaching staff announcement elicits some amused responses from fans

  • 2 WEEKS AGO

    Comedy gold as Toronto lock attempts clearance kick in MLR match featuring Matt Giteau and Adam Ashley-Cooper

  • 3 WEEKS AGO

    WATCH: 135kg prop lines up swan dive from 20 metres out... then re-thinks

View All

Amateur

  • 24 WEEKS AGO

    Viral video of Scottish club brawl goes down a storm with rugby community

  • 62 WEEKS AGO

    RUGBYDUMP BLITZ: This Best of the Week round up is sure to entertain you

  • 62 WEEKS AGO

    RD BLITZ - Disaster, just when it looked so promising...

  • 62 WEEKS AGO

    That glorious moment that will live on forever, like it or not

  • 62 WEEKS AGO

    RD Blitz - PROP'S Lionel Messi wizardy creates incredible try

View All

Player Features

  • 8 WEEKS AGO

    WATCH: Bumping off tacklers and taking high balls, Rob Kearney had an impressive Super Rugby debut

  • 14 WEEKS AGO

    Brian Moore on money in modern rugby and how it should never be compared to 'outlier' football

  • 15 WEEKS AGO

    Tuisova's wrecking ball montage will make you grateful you never made it as a pro

  • 21 WEEKS AGO

    New Zealand rugby pod admit Owen Farrell is world class

  • 22 WEEKS AGO

    WATCH: Bath prop launches Amazon documentary focused on those from non-traditional backgrounds

View All
Comparing the Jared Payne and Michael Rhodes cards for similar incidents | RugbyDump - Rugby News & Videos