Sunday Jul 8, 2018 Straight red prompts calls for report system after Semisi Masirewa challenge

Straight red prompts calls for report system after Semisi Masirewa challenge
6
Comments

Sunwolves winger Semisi Masirewa will miss the rest of the Super Rugby season after he was sent off for a dangerous tackle on Bernard Foley. The game was evenly poised at the time, but then floodgates opened, and the Waratahs won 77-25.

Masirewa was red carded just before half time, in what has been called a pivotal moment in the match. 

His dangerous tackle on Foley, in which the Waratahs playmaker landed head first, led to a straight sending off and a subsequent disciplinary hearing. 

Sunwolves coach Tony Brown felt there wasn’t much in it. 

“I don’t think there’s any intent in there. It was just unfortunate,” he said post match. 

“I think it was Steve Hansen that said we should just put players on report, like they do in [rugby] League, and play on.”

Waratahs coach Darryl Gibson concurred with that approach. “I certainly support that, the effect that it [the red card] has on the game takes away from the contest. 

“In that [particular] instance, the referee has no option. He’s following to the letter of the law and that’s what he’s required to do. Having an intermediary step that’s not quite a red card – give him some options – sensible.” 

Mesirewa was today suspended for three weeks, after a SANZAAR Foul Play Review Committee accepted his guilty plea.

He was charged with contravening Law 9.18: A player must not lift an opponent off the ground and drop or drive that player so that their head and/or upper body make contact with the ground.

In his finding, Foul Play Review Committee Chairman Nigel Hampton QC ruled the following:

“Having conducted a detailed review of all the available evidence, including all camera angles and a statement from the player and submissions from his legal representative, Maryjane Crabtree, the Foul Play Review Committee upheld the Red Card under Law 9.18.

“With respect to sanction the Foul Play Review Committee deemed the act of foul play merited a low-end entry point of 6 weeks. However, taking into account mitigating factors including the Player’s good judicial record, his immediate and repeated apology to the other player, his remorse and his guilty plea at the earliest possible convenience, the Foul Play Review Committee reduced the suspension to 3 weeks.”

“The player is therefore suspended for 3 weeks, up to and including 30 July 2018.”

The Waratahs’ convincing victory took them to second in the table behind the Crusaders.

Watch another angle of the challenge in this video:

Red the right call? #WARvSUN

A post shared by rugby.com.au (@rugbycomau) on Jul 7, 2018 at 7:45am PDT

Watch full match highlights here:

credit: superrugbytv

6 Comments

  •  pickay
    pickay

    Couldn't agree more! I get annoyed every time they are studying the replay in super-duper ultra slow motion, almost frame by frame, and then decide the player had plenty of time to pull out of the tackle, or that a player lost control of the ball when he actually had it all the time, or whatever else they could find... Reality just doesn't work frame by frame, you need to take the dynamics of the situation into account.

    Reply
  •  anton
    anton

    At least, TMO should review in real speed, in slow motion, everything looks dangerous and intentional.

    Reply
  •  drg
    drg

    Actually, to add, I personally don't have an issue with red/yellow cards, Jamie Cuddles Cudmore has well and truly earned his fair share, Andy Hazel going batshit crazy deserved his, despite me thinking it was fair retribution, but the issue is crap laws leading to crap application.

    Reply
  •  pickay
    pickay

    Well put, mate. Let the boys play rugby. Another frustrating outcome. No malicious intent whatsoever. He didn't even properly lift him, Foley's centre of gravity doesn't go anywhere, the fall is from like half a metre above ground. But sure he got tipped over and sure he landed on his head, so there's your automatic red card. Sometimes it feels like tackling in rugby has become like playing Russian roulette.

    Reply
  •  drg
    drg

    Did Foley ham that up a bit? "His dangerous tackle on Foley, in which the Waratahs playmaker landed head first" Looks like his arm hit the deck first, then his shoulder then head, or shoulder and head...

    Reply
  •  finedisregard
    finedisregard

    Please let these guys play. Stop red and yellow cards. It ruins the contest.

    Reply

Great Tries

View All

Big Hits & Dirty Play

View All

See It To Believe It

View All

Funnies

View All

Training Videos

View All

Player Features

View All
Straight red prompts calls for report system after Semisi Masirewa challenge | RugbyDump