ADVERTISEMENT
RugbyDump
REGISTER
LOGIN
ADVERTISEMENT
RugbyDump
Wednesday Apr 24, 2019

Bryce Heem remains suspended after appeal against lengthy ban was dismissed

Worcester Warriors’ Bryce Heem appeared before an independent disciplinary panel to appeal the four-week suspension he was given for a tip tackle during the match between Worcester Warriors and Sale Sharks. 

ADVERTISEMENT

Former New Zealand 7s player Heem got a yellow card after he was deemed to have picked up and dumped Paolo Odogwu dangerously, contrary to Law 9.18.

He appealed his suspension, and after it was heard by a new panel comprising Gareth Graham (chair), His Honour Judge Martin Picton and John Doubleday, it was dismissed and he remains suspended for four weeks.

Panel chair Gareth Graham said:

“The issue on appeal was whether the disciplinary panel who heard the case at first instance was wrong to conclude that the “tip-tackle” by the player on Paolo Odogwu passed the red-card test.

“The player accepted before the appeal panel that there was an act of foul play and that it warranted a yellow card. This represented a change of stance from that adopted at the original hearing when the question as to whether the player’s action amounted to an act of foul play was challenged.

“The disciplinary panel at first instance gave limited reasons as to why it considered the red-card threshold was passed. In our view, it simply adopted a submission made on behalf of the RFU that if a player who had been tip-tackled landed on the head, neck or shoulder, a red card is warranted for the tackler, whereas a yellow card is warranted where a player lands on the back or side.

ADVERTISEMENT

“At the appeal, counsel for the RFU was unable to demonstrate to the appeal panel the existence of any such guidance (either formally or informally). In the view of the appeal panel, this approach by the disciplinary panel was flawed.

“Instead, the assessment of whether a particular tip-tackle satisfies the red-card test requires an analysis of all three elements of the act of foul play – (a) lifting off the ground (b) dropping or driving and (c) head and/or upper body making contact with the ground.

“The decision as to whether a particular tip-tackle should attract a yellow or red card does not necessarily depend on whether a tackled player lands on one part of the upper body or another. We concluded that an act of foul play which causes another player to land on the shoulder (as part of a tip-tackle) does not automatically warrant a red card as opposed to a yellow card; the appropriate sanction depends on the circumstances of the particular act of foul play in question. 

ADVERTISEMENT

“As a consequence, we consider that the decision reached by the disciplinary panel was flawed in that it was made on an overly simplistic and misguided basis.

“On an appeal the discretion afforded by the RFU Regulations, in particular RFU Regulation 19.12.12, is wide. That discretion includes dismissing the appeal, quashing a finding and any sanction imposed, remitting the matter for a re-hearing or substituting an alternative finding and/or sanction. 

“The appeal panel concluded, however, that sufficient facts were available to us in the reasoning of the disciplinary panel, supplemented by the video footage, so as to allow us to properly make our own assessment as to whether the decision that the tackle justified a red card was the correct one.

“In so deciding we were conscious that we should not substitute our own views of the facts for that of the disciplinary panel but were confident that we could reach a fair assessment of the issue on the available material.

“We concluded that the tackle did pass the red card threshold. This conclusion was based on the overall circumstances of the tackle, including that the player lifted Paolo Odogwu beyond the horizontal and dropped him on his shoulder. In the appeal panel’s assessment, this was a tip-tackle where the nature of the landing was potentially very dangerous to the tackled player and thus a red-card was justified in the circumstances.

“There was no appeal against the sanction (of a four-week ban) to be applied to the player if the appeal panel concluded that the red card threshold was passed. The appeal is therefore dismissed and the original sanction remains in place.”

You can view the tackle above and then briefly in the match highlights below.

credit: premiershiprugby

Related Articles

  • 26 WEEKS AGO

    Montage of HUGE hits and brilliant tries...

  • 26 WEEKS AGO

    Just Jonny Wilkinson smashing people

  • 27 WEEKS AGO

    New Zealand Rugby Brawl



ADVERTISEMENT

Great Tries

  • 2 DAYS AGO

    Faf De Klerk Involved With Wild Trick Play In Japanese Top League

  • 2 DAYS AGO

    Italian Star With A Mind Blowing Finish For Toulouse

  • 2 WEEKS AGO

    Quick Thinking Etzebeth Scores Thrilling Try To Keep Sharks Alive In London

  • 4 WEEKS AGO

    Carlin Isles scores cracking tries in return to sevens rugby

  • 4 WEEKS AGO

    Chaotic try in classic footage shows just how unpredictable a rugby ball can be

View All

Big Hits & Dirty Play

  • 2 DAYS AGO

    Nasty Stamp During Top 14 Clash Caught Up Close On Camera

  • 3 DAYS AGO

    Leicester Tigers And Springbok Number Eight In Hot Water For Sickening Ankle Roll

  • 1 WEEK AGO

    Controversy Brewing Following Lack Of TMO intervention In ‘Dangerous’ Toulouse Tackle

  • 1 WEEK AGO

    Toulouse demonstrate power with spine tingling hits

  • 2 WEEKS AGO

    Ugly Club Rugby Incident Caught On Camera

View All

See It To Believe It

  • 3 DAYS AGO

    Sevens magic as 'headed' try brings stadium to its feet

  • 2 WEEKS AGO

    Almost 35,000 have now signed petition to reverse new grassroots tackle laws

  • 2 WEEKS AGO

    RFU introduce maximum of waist high tackling in amateur rugby

  • 2 WEEKS AGO

    Big players omitted in Borthwick's new squad and Jones finds a new job - The fallout

  • 4 WEEKS AGO

    Chaotic try in classic footage shows just how unpredictable a rugby ball can be

View All

Funnies

  • 2 DAYS AGO

    Faf De Klerk Involved With Wild Trick Play In Japanese Top League

  • 3 DAYS AGO

    Sevens magic as 'headed' try brings stadium to its feet

  • 3 DAYS AGO

    Australian Broadcasters Slammed For ‘Pathetic’ Attack On International Referee

  • 3 WEEKS AGO

    “I’m Too Old” Referee Substituted In Bizarre Incident

  • 3 WEEKS AGO

    Bad day for referee Adam Leal as he takes a battering and then gets called by the wrong name

View All

Amateur

  • 3 WEEKS AGO

    You Won’t See Many Better Than This Silky-Smooth Try From Llandovery RFC

  • 3 WEEKS AGO

    Incredible Scenes As Caldy RFC Hand Ealing First Championship Defeat Of The Season

  • 26 WEEKS AGO

    Dubious Score Decides Result Of Rugby's Biggest Schools Fixture

  • 26 WEEKS AGO

    Incredible Scenes At School Boys Rugby Match

  • 27 WEEKS AGO

    The Next Dominant Backrow?

View All

Player Features

  • 2 DAYS AGO

    Sarah Mckenna plays crossbar challenge with cheeky drop goal

  • 2 DAYS AGO

    Capuozzo shows class with 'superman' flying finish

  • 3 DAYS AGO

    Slade out and Lions star in as England injuries cause changes

  • 6 DAYS AGO

    Josh Bassett signs for new premiership team after short stay at Harlequins

  • 2 WEEKS AGO

    Exeter fly half to depart for France

View All