Do Not Sell My Personal Information
RugbyDump RugbyDump
Friday Sep 27, 2019

Pros give their verdict on the Piers Francis tackle that could have been the quickest ever red card

Pros give their verdict on the Piers Francis tackle that could have been the quickest ever red card

Piers Francis almost had the shortest debut in Rugby World Cup history in England’s match against the USA on Thursday. In fact, it would have been the shortest appearance ever in a RWC match when he collided with Will Hooley in the very first tackle of the match, making contact with his head.

High tackles have undoubtedly been the most debated topic of the RWC so far, and it only took five seconds before there was another tackle that was added to the catalogue of controversial hits at this year’s tournament. The referee Nic Berry missed it on that occasion, but there are expected to be ramifications.

In light of the tackle, former and current professionals have had their say, and what should be the outcome. Jamie Roberts was one to point out if Australia’s Reece Hodge’s three-week ban set the standard at this RWC, Francis should expect the same punishment.

Both Francis’ and Hodge’s tackles are comparable, although Hooley had dipped into the tackle slightly more than Peceli Yato had, and it could be argued that Francis initially hit the shoulders and slid up.

Then again, the Northampton Saints centre was coming in at a greater speed, and it could therefore be deemed to be more reckless. What does come across is that neither player showed any malice, if that does count for anything.

Former Wallabies winger Drew Mitchell, who has been very critical of the decision to ban Hodge, posed the question on Twitter as to what Francis should expect, and another three-week ban seems to be the verdict.

Hodge was initially banned for six weeks, but it was halved based on his character and record, so the same should be expected for Francis.

There were a couple of incidents in this match that were missed, although John Quill’s heinous challenge to the head of Owen Farrell was not. The flanker saw red, and it is highly unlikely that he will play again at this tournament, as he’s just been suspended for three weeks.

With the tournament not even a week old, there have already been three suspensions to date, which suggests this could be the defining feature of this year’s RWC.

Francis will face a discplinary hearing at a date yet to be determined.


  • Joe Sweeney
    5:25 PM 01/10/2019

    New High Tackle Protocol for RWC 2019:1. High tackle by Tier II nation against Tier I star player.  Immediate red card.2. High tackle by Tier I nation against Pacific Islander. Leave the player on the field to be reviewed later - wouldn't want to upset the flow of the match.3. High tackle by Tier I player against Tier II.  No penalty - the minnows are lucky we allow them in here anyway.


Great Tries

View All

Big Hits & Dirty Play

View All

See It To Believe It

View All


View All


View All

Player Features

View All
Pros give their verdict on the Piers Francis tackle that could have been the quickest ever red card | RugbyDump - Rugby News & Videos