Tuesday Jun 26, 2018 Calls for one man lifts to be outlawed as Israel Folau readies for judicial hearing

Calls for one man lifts to be outlawed as Israel Folau readies for judicial hearing
11
Comments

Israel Folau’s disciplinary hearing will take place tomorrow (Wednesday) afternoon in Sydney, and will determine whether the Waratahs fullback will be suspended for this weekend’s round of Super Rugby matches. It’s caused some concern for assistant coach Simon Cron.

The talented Wallabies fullback was yellow carded during the 20-16 loss to Ireland on Saturday, after it was ruled that he pulled down Peter O’Mahony when competing under a high ball.

After being cited, he will face a World Rugby judicial panel comprising of Shao Wang (Chair, Singapore), Val Toma (Romania), and Eroni Clarke (NZ).

Waratahs assistant coach Simon Cron has stood by his man, concerned that he will miss the Waratahs’ Friday night clash with the Melbourne Rebels.

Cron suggested that World Rugby who needed to reacquaint themselves with their own rules.

“Personally, I think it’s an interesting decision to even send him there,” Cron told reporters. “I would think (Ireland would) look at their one-man lifting technique. I know, we do a lot of it.

“I’d be surprised. It’d be a bit of a nanny state if they pull him.

“My understanding of the law is that when you’re both competing for the ball, you’re both competing for the ball. The only way around that is maybe we change the sport and say you’re not allowed to leave the ground and turn it into under-12s. I’m not sure.

“We’ve had presentation after presentation… we’ve had (referee) Angus Gardner in here and he’s shown us video of what goes, what doesn’t. We’re really clear on what we think you’re allowed to do and not allowed to do. And it states it in the law. So I’d be surprised if it changes.

“I think they just need to revisit it themselves, probably.”

Folau, arguably the best in the world currently at competing under the high ball, combines his skill with that of Bernard Foley, who manages to replicate perfectly placed kick-off restarts time and time again.

Folau was cited for the incident in the ninth minute, and later yellow carded for a similar tackle in the air on O’Mahony, with citing commissioner Michael O’Leary describing Folau’s actions as ‘strikingly similar’ to the contest for which he was yellow-carded.

Under World Rugby’s Regulation 17.25.3 (b), the combination of the yellow card and post-match citation means the incident must be treated as a red card and will go to a disciplinary hearing.

Here is a look at three of the contests in the air, showing how similar they are and that perhaps, as Cron says, then one man lift is more to blame that Folau himself.

CJ Stander meanwhile, the lifter, has taken a bit of responsibility for what happened.

“It’s a tough one, because I’m the one lifting him and I need to look after him,” Stander said. “It’s just that Folau is unbelievable in the air, it’s one of those ones where you need to go back and look at it and he got a yellow card.

“It’s tough, Pete [O’Mahony] got injured because of it. It’s something we worked on during the week, we knew it was going to come, I could have probably protected him a bit better.”

Former Leinster head coach Matt Williams has suggested that one-man lifts should be outlawed.

UPDATE: Israel Folau has been banned for one match. Rugby Australia will reportedly appeal the decision.

credit: rugbycomau/offtheball

11 Comments

  •  ruckinmaul
    ruckinmaul

    I knew this is a month old post, but I just knew/realise Fall's red card has been rescinded, and Folau has been banned for one match by the WR judicial. WR is in a pathetic state I must say. Inconsistent at the highest level possible.

    Reply
  •  danknapp
    danknapp

    Folau does sound a bit French, to be fair.

    Reply
  •  drg
    drg

    Oh, POM got injured... Fine.. ban him for 8 years..

    Reply
  •  rugbydump
    rugbydump

    UPDATE: Israel Folau has been banned for one match. Rugby Australia will reportedly appeal the decision.

    Reply
  •  drg
    drg

    Or two teams competing for the ball, a collision was made in the air as two players tried to get the ball, neither player afaik was injured so how about move on...

    Reply
  •  drg
    drg

    Only if we provide neck braces to all who enter the castle!

    Reply
  •  rdump0
    rdump0

    and in a bouncing castle...

    Reply
  •  rdump0
    rdump0

    Folau jumps in the air and plays the ball Stander lifts O'Mahony and doesn't ensure he returns safely to ground. Surely Stander is the one who should get cited?

    Reply
  •  mise
    mise

    Its hard to see them all properly ,but there was also talk of the one arm one man lift (hence the reference to one man lifting technique in the above). Whatever about one man ,one arm is well risky (allows for too much turning in the sky)

    Reply
  •  drg
    drg

    Can't we just play with a balloon instead, it'll make the game a lot slower and gentler...

    Reply
  •  im1
    im1

    everyone happy to not bother commenting on this as we have been through the same argument multiple times already?

    Reply

Great Tries

View All

Big Hits & Dirty Play

View All

See It To Believe It

View All

Funnies

View All

Training Videos

View All

Player Features

View All
Calls for one man lifts to be outlawed as Israel Folau readies for judicial hearing | RugbyDump