RugbyDump RugbyDump
Saturday Apr 11, 2015

Karmichael Hunt and the ARU's realistic response

Karmichael Hunt and the ARU's realistic response
5
Comments

The Reds are on the ropes, winless since round 2 and facing a huge injury crisis. But perhaps the most interesting subplot of the situation is the subsequent fast tracking of Karmichael Hunt’s shot at atonement. Josh Bristow takes a closer look.

With James O’Connor out for one week Hunt has regained the starting fullback position for Queensland’s match against the Bulls on Saturday.

It will be the first real step on the former league internationals path to redemption.

It’s not hard to forget the gut punch Queensland fans received when news broke that Hunt was to be charged with cocaine supply.

Here was the teams biggest off season signing in years, an athlete who could provide the power, finesse and experience from Rugby League combined with four years worth of kicking lessons in the Australian Football League.

The only other player to have travelled the same path to Super Rugby is Israel Folau, who became the best back in Australia within six months.

The Reds were signing Hunt, arguably the better NRL player and inarguably the better Aussie Rules footballer; he’d even played in a Heineken Cup Final!

Combined with a 2014 season where Queensland finally came crashing down to the reality of a post 2011 world, it was hard not to be excited.

With fans finding the shock of the situation hard to deal with, the decision by the ARU and the QRU to stick by Hunt angered many but on reflection it has been the right decision.

Admittedly if the Reds weren’t circling the wooden spoon Hunt would be playing Rugby League in Northern England faster than one could utter “Wendell Sailor”.

The full story won’t be finalized until the five Gold Coast Titans Rugby League players who were charged alongside Hunt have had their day in court, but Karmichael’s rap sheet is hardly gripping reading.

Karmichael pleaded guilty to possession of cocaine, which is a crime for sure, but one that the legal system decided required no conviction and a paltry $2,500 fine.

It’s a far distance away from when the Queensland Crime and Corruption Commission triumphantly declared that Hunt and other footballers would be charged with supply of the class-A drug.

Bizarrely, Hunt was initially charged with supplying himself – another sign that this ‘drug-bust’ (one with a guaranteed media interest) might have been more about appearing to do something on the QCAC’s part than actually safeguarding the community.

Hunt admits he took the drug on a month long end of season party that concluded his final season in the AFL.

Therefore calls for him to be immediately sacked a la Wendell Sailor were an overreaction.

Sailor was sacked because Cocaine is considered a performance enhancing drug and he was caught mid-season which gave the ARU immediate cause for dismissal.

Out of season and committed when he wasn’t technically an employee of the Reds, Hunt’s transgression is more of a moral quandary.

Undoubtedly drugs are a terrible scourge on modern society but the reality is if we were to sack every player who has ever tried drugs socially, we wouldn’t have a competition.

Karmichael’s real punishment is the difficulty he will now have attracting third party sponsors and the decreased opportunity to prove himself worthy of international honors.

Because Hunt can play, don’t kid yourself thinking anything else.

The only question is whether the woeful Reds pack can give him and Quade Cooper the platform they need to shine.

That leaves the journey to win back the minds of Reds and Wallaby fans, many of whom believe the slap on the wrist given to Hunt shatters the integrity of both organisations.

If Hunt makes the World Cup squad expect another outpouring of moral crusaders but surely if that happens he will have earned it through his actions on the field.

It is hard to recall if there was the same amount of disappointment in Kurtley Beale’s swift reinstatement last year.

The Jeremy Clarkson of Australian Rugby has built up his own rap sheet of incidents including punching a co-worker, sexual harassment and substance abuse that directly resulted in physical harm to others.

Despite this most forgave Beale after he played a huge role in the Waratahs Super Rugby triumph and put in solid performances for the Wallabies last year.

This discrepancy between the moral outrage towards drug use and the muted response to sexual harassment and alcohol abuse is another topic and an issue that transcends the world of sport, where players are forgiven if they can throw a ball around.

Therefore it is up to the individual to decide where they place recreational drug use on the sliding scale of unforgiveable acts, but you can be sure if Karmichael Hunt scores the winning try in a RWC final Australian fans will be cheering in unison.

Come Saturday evening, that’s all up to Hunt. 

– Josh Bristow

5 Comments

  •  stroudos
    stroudos
    9:01 PM 14/04/2015

    Cheers for the reply. Didn't intend to be critical of the actual piece - it's pretty entertaining - just seemed at odds with your usual "house style"!

    Reply
  •  rugbydump
    rugbydump
    10:46 AM 14/04/2015

    Thanks for the feedback. Josh is part of the team and will be doing the occasional piece, sometimes about Australian rugby specifically. He's from Brisbane, and a Reds fan, hence the slightly opinionated tone. Always happy to receive feedback though so your comments have been taken on board. Cheers, GC

    Reply
  •  stroudos
    stroudos
    1:20 PM 13/04/2015

    Unusual to read such an opinionated piece on Rugbydump. I'm a bit confused to be honest. Who is Josh Bristow? Perhaps this sort of commentary piece should be clearly signposted "Guest Blog Post" or something? One of the - many - brilliant things about Rugbydump is that, although not afraid to articulate an opinion, the intros/write-ups tend to be written in a very balanced style and free of hyperbole. For me, this is not the case here.

    Reply
  •  drg
    drg
    10:38 PM 12/04/2015

    Mixed reviews. On one hand the guy was 'punished' did his time (or paid his fine) and therefore should he not have a chance to continue with his life. If you get caught speeding you pay your fine and on you go without much hindrance.. But then on the other hand, it's supplying... who cares if he wants to load himself up with the drug.. but others, that is another matter... And then... drugs are drugs, but as RD said, Kurtley Beale who can't keep his hands to himself gets another go - isn't that worse?

    Reply
  • 10:41 AM 12/04/2015

    Wonderfull to see that Rugbydump seems to share the ARU's and the Red's type of morals. - "Accused of consuming and distributing a substance seen as a performer enhancer? Even if out of season, the substance is a hard drug and would land most non famous people/sporstman in jail?" "Weeeeeelllll, we will forgive you if you are really good at rugby and play well in your upcoming games. Who knows, you might even play well for our national squad, being elevated to hero and role model to thousands of kids (who certainly wouldn't be treated with the same lenience in this situation, damn peasants)! Here's a shot at redemption for ya!" - "Let's call everyone who thinks he shouldn't get away with a ridiculously lenient punishment just because he's famous a moral crusader, though. That will teach them to have double standards, like us. Also, let's use the "Come on, all the other cool kids do it too" excuse. Hey, it worked in high school when I tried to get into Cindy Morris' pants at that party"

    Reply

Related Articles



Great Tries

View All

Big Hits & Dirty Play

View All

See It To Believe It

View All

Funnies

View All

Amateur

View All

Player Features

View All
Karmichael Hunt and the ARU's realistic response | RugbyDump - Rugby News & Videos