RugbyDump RugbyDump
Thursday Sep 20, 2018

Bastareaud ban viewed as light after he deliberately struck a player on the back of the head

Bastareaud ban viewed as light after he deliberately struck a player on the back of the head
4
Comments

Toulon back Mathieu Bastareaud has been suspended following the red card he received for striking a prone Christophe Samson on the back of the head. While his disciplinary record added a week, some were removed for his good behaviour and remorse at the hearing.

A LNR disciplinary found that he was responsible for striking with the arms, which is listed as medium degree of severity on their range of offences, particularly due to the head of the opponent having been hit.

That is an automatic 6-week ban, but due to aggravating circumstances – such as his record – another week was added to his suspension.

But due to his recognition of guilt, conduct before and during the hearing and his show of remorse, the sanction was reduced by a further 2 weeks. Therefore Bastareaud has been suspended from all forms of rugby for 5 weeks.

Considering the offence and the deliberate nature of it, some felt that he got off lightly.

While others called for more consistency when different foul play incidents are compared.

Off the rugby field this would be a far more serious offence.

What do you think of the 5 week ban?

ANOTHER BAN
In other disciplinary news from the Top 14, Tony Ensor has also been suspended for 5 weeks after his dangerous lifting tackle on Flip van der Merwe. Video below and more on that incident here.

4 Comments

  •  alasdairduncan3
    alasdairduncan3
    Top Comment

    "Outside the rugby pitch it would be classified as an assault!" As would a rugby tackle. Pick a better argument, there are plenty.

    Reply
  •  colombes
    colombes

    Balanced sanction for BastareaudExaggerated sanction for SpencerEnd.

    Reply
  •  pmew
    pmew

    Completely agree with Michael Barrett’s tweet - one week more than poor Will Spencer is a total joke.

    Reply
    •  pickay
      pickay

      I agree with that too. But I think Bastareaud's ban is about appropriate, and Spencer's is way too long.

      Reply

Great Tries

View All

Big Hits & Dirty Play

View All

See It To Believe It

View All

Funnies

View All

Training Videos

View All

Player Features

View All
Bastareaud ban viewed as light after he deliberately struck a player on the back of the head | RugbyDump - Rugby News & Videos