Do Not Sell My Personal Information
RugbyDump RugbyDump
Wednesday Feb 20, 2019

Officials have backtracked after new evidence shows that Tomkinson's red card featured no foul play

Officials have backtracked after new evidence shows that Tomkinson's red card featured no foul play

After receiving a red card against the Chiefs, Highlanders back Sio Tomkinson has received some good news following a disciplinary hearing via video conference. Tomkinson was sent off for his no-arms shoulder tackle on Brodie Retallick in the opening weekend of Super Rugby.

The decision at the time was viewed as an “incredibly harsh red card” and stirred debate amongst fans and pundits.

After a thorough examination of the incident, a SANZAAR Judicial Committee Hearing found Tomkinson not guilty of contravening Law 9.13 Dangerous Tackling and Law 9.16 Dangerous Charge.

Law 9.13: A player must not tackle an opponent early, late or dangerously. Dangerous tackling includes, but is not limited to, tackling or attempting to tackle an opponent above the line of the shoulders even if the tackle starts below the line of the shoulders
Law 9.16: A player must not charge or knock down an opponent carrying the ball without attempting to grasp that player.

In his finding, the Judicial Committee Chairman Michael Heron QC ruled the following:

“The Judicial Committee conducted a detailed review of all the available evidence, including all camera angles and relevant match reports. The Committee heard evidence from the player, a member of the Highlanders’ coaching staff, and received submissions from his legal representative, Aaron Lloyd.

“The Committee adjourned the hearing to make further inquiries with the match referee and received additional information from him. With the benefit of this further information, the Judicial Committee was satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the referee was wrong in issuing the Red Card. The Committee determined to remove the red card from the Player’s record.

“The Judicial Committee found that the Player made contact with his shoulder to the shoulder of the Chiefs player. On careful review of the footage, and on receiving further evidence, the Committee determined that the Player did not make contact with the head of the Chiefs player and he did attempt to use his arm in the attempted tackle.

“Due to the rapid change in angle from the Chiefs player, and the tackle of the other Highlanders player involved, the incident appeared to be more significant that it was. The Committee had the benefit of lengthy analysis and review of the footage and the other evidence which enabled it to determine that there was no contact to the head by the Player and no foul play.

“Accordingly, there was not a breach of Law 9.13 or 9.16. The player is therefore free to play.”

Tomkinson will therefore be up for selection when the Highlanders host the Reds in Dunedin on Friday.


Fri 22 February: Highlanders v Reds @ Forsyth Barr Stadium, Dunedin (19:35)
Sat 23 February: Sunwolves v Waratahs @ Prince Chichibu Stadium Tokyo (13:15)
Sat 23 February: Crusaders v Hurricanes @ Christchurch Stadium, Christchurch (19:35)
Sat 23 February: Brumbies v Chiefs @ GIO Stadium, Canberra (19:45)
Sat 23 February: Sharks v Blues @ Jonsson Kings Park, Durban (15:05)
Sat 23 February: Stormers v Lions @ DHL Newlands, Cape Town (17:15)
Sat 23 February: Jaguares v Bulls @ Jose Amalfitani Stadium, Buenos Aires (18:40)
Bye: Rebels

*all times local


Great Tries

View All

Big Hits & Dirty Play

View All

See It To Believe It

View All


View All


View All

Player Features

View All
Officials have backtracked after new evidence shows that Tomkinson's red card featured no foul play | RugbyDump - Rugby News & Videos