ADVERTISEMENT
RugbyDump
REGISTER
LOGIN
ADVERTISEMENT
RugbyDump
Tuesday Jul 25, 2023

Former England scrum half Joe Simpson gives opinion on England number nine choices and caterpillar rucks

The choice of scrum-half has been a subject of contention for England fans, coaches, and pundits alike for many years now. Since the early 2010s, there has been a fight for the jersey between Ben Youngs and Danny Care in particular.

ADVERTISEMENT

It was a tight battle over the number 9 shirt that lasted for just under 10 years before Care was dropped in 2018 after an ill-fated match against Japan. From then on, Ben Youngs was given the rights over the shirt, for which he helped control one of the most successful periods of English rugby in modern times.

Questions have arisen over the past few years, however, particularly concerning Young‘s decision-making and ability to remain at the highest level. Up until recently, with the emergence of the young Leicester Tiger, Jack van Poortvliet, there were no real challengers for Youngs’ position.

That all changed following the summer tour to Australia last year, in which Van Poortvliet came off the bench in the first test to add some real zip to the English attack. It was a tour without Youngs that also saw the reintroduction of Danny Care after 4 years in the international wilderness. These inclusions led many to believe that Youngs may see his way back into the England squad blocked by new talent and an in-form Care.

The final match of the Australian tour proved calamitous for the experienced Care, however, after being dragged off by Eddie Jones after just 36 minutes due to a lack of control on the game. This for many appeared to be the end of the spritely scrum half’s England career.

danny care

ADVERTISEMENT

This, as it turned out, was not to be – following the change in leadership with former Leicester Head Coach, Steve Borthwick, taking up the reins.

Following numerous squad announcements, it has appeared that the former Bath and Saracens captain, now England Head Coach, Borthwick, has elected for both experienced number 9s Danny Care and Ben Youngs to be included in the squad. Their combined 209 caps for the national side gives Borthwick impressive options alongside the 12-cap youngster, Jack van Poortvliet.

The Telegraph has been speaking to former England scrumhalf Joe Simpson about the potential of the England scrum-half choices.

“We haven’t seen that many nines come through in the last decade, which is mainly testament to Ben,” Simpson said about Ben Youngs’ longevity in the squad.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I think he’s been fantastic for England, a top-quality international scrum-half. Consistently competing at that level is phenomenal. He’s been the stalwart and Danny has been there for a few years, too.”

It is a testament to Youngs and Care that since the formers debut back in 2010, they have owned 75% of all starts at scrumhalf between them, leaving other players, including Simpson himself, Dan Robson, and several other promising young players, to make do with only substitute appearances.

It is, however, Youngs’ decision-making, particularly around the ruck that many have had issues with. Rugby is a game that many want to see as free-flowing and attacking from everywhere on the field, but as Simpson says, the ability to control a game and slow it down where necessary can separate the good from the great.

“Rugby is full of opinions and most of them come from people with no understanding of rugby” continued Simpson. “Everyone seems to have a romanticised idea of what winning rugby is because they played at under-15 level and remember running the ball and scoring tries.

“Particularly at international level, defences are so good that it is so hard to break things down. The risk-reward of playing from your half is just off. Any mistake and you give away a penalty and your opposition will kick three points or bang it to within five metres. If you throw caution to the wind and run from your own half, you’re likely to get stung.

“The complaints have to be with people that make the laws rather than players that interpret them. I’m telling you now, people would be even more miffed if their team ran the ball from deep and lost control of the game.”

This being said, the multi-club scrum-half has found a particular issue with the modern caterpillar ruck:

“Caterpillar rucks are a travesty. I earned lots of my money from box-kicking tens of thousands of times but it’s not enjoyable. If you listed out what you wanted to see on a rugby pitch, I don’t think high-ball competitions between the touchlines and 15-metres lines would be high on anyone’s list. Maybe just above re-set scrums? Why is there a law that presents an advantage to slowing the game down?

“Caterpillar rucks don’t make sense. There is a five-second law that is not enforced. Get rid of caterpillar rucks, make it easier for scrum-halves to be charged down. Then teams will kick off 10 [from fly-half] more. That’s a quicker kick that will aim to go to space.”

“I’m not encouraging England to pick livewires and throw it about, that’s not the best way for them to win a World Cup.

“Nine is obviously such a key position and so many teams are taught to be conservative,” he adds. “At Gloucester and Bath, the game-plan was to box-kick to compete from our own try-line up until even the opposition 10-metre line. You box-kick, you compete for a 50-50 and then if you lose the ball, you back your defence.

“That culture lends itself to defensive, tactical players. That’s probably why we saw Willi Heinz go to a World Cup. He’s a fantastic player with a great pass, but it was his sense of control on a game. Alex Mitchell, I think, is brilliant. He’s probably the best attacking scrum-half we’ve got in the UK. But he doesn’t get a sniff, probably because he doesn’t suit England’s game plan. He’s a livewire, but probably can’t bring that control.

It’s this game management that has led Simpson to believe that Youngs and Poortvliet will be more likely to get the nod than the “instinctive” Care.

“Don’t get me wrong, Ben and Jack have the ability to snipe, but their X-factor is being able to put the ball up and conserve the energy of their forwards. We’ve seen a preference towards controlling scrum-halves rather than instinctive ones. I don’t think that’s doing anyone a disservice, because Ben is a fine player on his day.”

Comments




Related Articles

  • 37 WEEKS AGO

    South African winger tipped to break Rugby...

  • 37 WEEKS AGO

    Springboks make sweeping changes for final...

  • 37 WEEKS AGO

    Quade Cooper puts out wild request to Saudi...



ADVERTISEMENT

Great Tries

  • 4 DAYS AGO

    Five of the best tries from the Investec Champions Cup

  • 11 WEEKS AGO

    The dummy that sold the whole of Perth - including the cameraman

  • 11 WEEKS AGO

    Bayonne score 'one of the best tries you'll ever see' in latest match against Exeter

  • 12 WEEKS AGO

    Baloucoune shows Andy Farrell what he's missing as the winger tears through Harlequins defence

  • 24 WEEKS AGO

    Seriously impressive Courtney Lawes compilation released after England player calls time on international career

View All

Big Hits & Dirty Play

  • 2 DAYS AGO

    Fiji Drua player Lomani slapped with ban following elbow attack

  • 10 WEEKS AGO

    The sending off that rocked the Six Nations opener

  • 11 WEEKS AGO

    Wrecking ball beats 10 players to score full length of the pitch try

  • 20 WEEKS AGO

    Streaker causes major bust up as he tackles player

  • 21 WEEKS AGO

    Monster hit from Perrin leaves Bristol Bears player stunned

View All

See It To Believe It

  • 3 DAYS AGO

    Tickets now on sale as World XV set to face France in thrilling encounter

  • 4 DAYS AGO

    '60 metres, plus change' - massive drop goal stuns fans

  • 4 DAYS AGO

    Referee makes 'tackle of the season' as he gets too close to the action

  • 2 WEEKS AGO

    Christian Wade proves he still has the X-factor with 50 metre mazy finish for Racing 92

  • 3 WEEKS AGO

    Magical sevens try leaves defender stuck in the mud

View All

Funnies

  • 1 WEEK AGO

    George Ford falls victim to the kickers curse

  • 2 WEEKS AGO

    Awesome scenes as Blitzbok fan throws down at the HSBC SVNS

  • 7 WEEKS AGO

    Mike Philips recounts crazy night Shane Williams tried to fight Warren Gatland

  • 11 WEEKS AGO

    Shaun Edwards leaves room silent in new Six Nations documentary with French to English transition

  • 20 WEEKS AGO

    Streaker causes major bust up as he tackles player

View All

Amateur

  • 65 WEEKS AGO

    You Won’t See Many Better Than This Silky-Smooth Try From Llandovery RFC

  • 66 WEEKS AGO

    Incredible Scenes As Caldy RFC Hand Ealing First Championship Defeat Of The Season

  • 89 WEEKS AGO

    Dubious Score Decides Result Of Rugby's Biggest Schools Fixture

  • 89 WEEKS AGO

    Incredible Scenes At School Boys Rugby Match

  • 89 WEEKS AGO

    The Next Dominant Backrow?

View All

Player Features

  • 14 HOURS AGO

    Mitch Drummond pays tribute to the Mo'unga family in emotional interview

  • 16 HOURS AGO

    Julian Savea rolls back the years with 'bus' style finish

  • 1 DAY AGO

    Saracens announce double retirement as club heads into rebuilding era

  • 2 DAYS AGO

    Fiji Drua player Lomani slapped with ban following elbow attack

  • 2 DAYS AGO

    Adam Hastings to exit Gloucester as new club confirmed

View All