Do Not Sell My Personal Information
RugbyDump RugbyDump
Friday Jan 6, 2017

After just one season, the future of PRO Rugby in the USA is uncertain

After just one season, the future of PRO Rugby in the USA is uncertain

With a second year of PRO Rugby in America still up in the air, we address a few of the issues and challenges it has faced, and take a quick look back with a video highlighting the best plays from the inaugural season.

It’s safe to say that there have been some serious growing pains for America’s maiden professional rugby competition. With one team – San Francisco – now defunct, there are some rather stinging accusations coming from both sides that contracts and sanctions have not been honoured. 

Players, announcers, and even vendors are claiming they are owed thousands of dollars from PRO Rugby CEO Doug Schoninger. Some have gone so far as to file suit in small claims court.

Former All Black Mils Muliaina, formerly of San Francisco, is claiming to still be owed $20,000 from Schoninger. Muliaina also had some particulary strong words for the setup overall:

“There was a lot said that they didn’t provide… I really actually felt for the people, they were really trying hard to make something like this… Unfortunately, in this instance you’ve got some really bad people trying to run something that they don’t know how to run.”

For his part, Schoninger takes exception to the overall attitude of some of his players, Muliaina specifically. According to his interview with Rugby Wrap Up, he claims that Muliaina showed up later than originally agreed upon, played a couple of games, then left without leave to go back to New Zealand for a week. 

He also states that Mils was claiming to be injured and, per disability laws in the United States and the state of California, the $20,000 is being filed through disability.

Schoninger also took exception to numerous players participating in unsanctioned events they claim to have had permission to attend. He claims otherwise and that he and former USA Rugby CEO Nigel Melville had a signed sanctions agreement.

Apparently, things have never been smooth between USA Rugby and PRO Rugby, to say the least. According to this interview, Melville never attended any PRO Rugby matches and only one match was attended by the US Eagles head coach.

Conditions escalated further when PRO Rugby effectively blamed USA Rugby in invoking their Voluntary Termination clause (section5(b)). Of course, USA Rugby categorically denied all accusations.

As the finger pointing and internet exchanges continue, one could assume these are the kinds of issues that may potentially arise at the outset of any professional league. However, the future does not look particularly bright as the news emerging continues to be more and more unsettling. 

It remains to be seen when, or even if, there will be a second season for PRO Rugby. Schoninger claims they are here to stay and that he’s already lined up another squad to replace San Francisco. 

Continued rugby growth in the states seems forever just one bounce away. Here’s hoping things can come together and vastly improve at all levels to actually see this dream fulfilled.

Credit: PRO Rugby


  • ispotts27
    4:24 AM 26/01/2017

    I think if they try again they will need at least one viable team on the East Coast. Boston and NY have some of the better amateur clubs in the US (look at the American Rugby Premiership). If USA Rugby finds a way to expand upon that rugby could easily gain better traction in the US.

  • coostov
    5:41 PM 10/01/2017

    This is a shame. Even though the business side of the league was mismanaged, the product was actually good and games were very entertaining to watch. The league did well to get the best players in USA amateur rugby, filling squads with Eagles, college All-Americans and a handful of capped international legends. I really hope USA Rugby can get something akin to this going again. With a proper business model, pro rugby in the US will flourish.

  • weejockmcplop
    5:34 PM 10/01/2017

    Maybe looking at how football (soccer) has developed i the US will give some hope for the long term. launched in the 70's it struggled with crowds and eventually petered out. Only with the World Cup and the establishment of a new league and the explosion in media coverage worldwide did it start to develop. It may be a similar story with rugby that requires some persistence and luck, but let's hope it develops as judging by the clips there's some great passing and handling skills on show

  • im1
    1:44 PM 07/01/2017

    2.07 mins in is the obvious highlight. seems a shame. the rugby on the video looks a fairly decent standard with some pretty good skills

  • drg
    12:23 AM 07/01/2017

    Oh well US, count yourselves lucky perhaps... You will get to miss out on bullshit cards and bullshit bans for nothing activities... Sad for rugby but like any business; that's right, "business", bad management will ruin it.

  • finedisregard
    4:33 PM 06/01/2017

    I live in the US and one of my friends and former teammates was the manager of one of these teams. This whole league was very badly mismanaged from the onset. Players, vendors, and staff were not paid in a timely way. There were issues with venues changing. There was also zero marketing, with no television presence or even websites. The local media did not even know about this league. This league was created by one guy that no background in rugby or even sports. He did not have as much money as he led the public to believe and the league now defunct.


Great Tries

View All

Big Hits & Dirty Play

View All

See It To Believe It

View All


View All


View All

Player Features

View All
After just one season, the future of PRO Rugby in the USA is uncertain | RugbyDump - Rugby News & Videos